List Curation Criticism
Comments primarily critique the quality, curation, length, and usefulness of a specific list in the HN post, advocating for tighter curation, commentary, or analysis over mere dumps of links.
Activity Over Time
Top Contributors
Keywords
Sample Comments
I don't think the list was meant to be exhaustive.
Seems like a more tightly curated list would be more valuable.
That list wasn't meant to be exhaustive.
I like this list, it addresses something most don't.
Lists are good but sometimes lists are not good.
That says more about the list makers.
I don't see why the list is deeply interesting. Maybe some analysis on the list would be more valuable than the list itself.
The lists we're good idea - but they are mostly lists - not really that curated.
I wish these lists were better curated rather than just a dump of links with no commentary.
The list isn't intended to be 100% serious.