YouTube Video Lengths

Cluster focuses on frustrations with YouTube's algorithm prioritizing long, padded videos for watch time and monetization over short, concise content, alongside mixed reactions to the push for YouTube Shorts.

➡️ Stable 0.8x Other
3,127
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#499
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
13
2009
14
2010
44
2011
39
2012
41
2013
92
2014
28
2015
50
2016
69
2017
76
2018
77
2019
94
2020
258
2021
244
2022
409
2023
511
2024
380
2025
669
2026
17

Keywords

OR XX AI UX TikTok YT YouTube HUGE DIY FYI videos shorts video youtube content short watching length blah tiktok

Sample Comments

Polylactic_acid Oct 22, 2020 View on HN

There is a difference between watching 6 second meme videos and full length content.

noobermin Jan 28, 2024 View on HN

My guess is the video is too long because absolutely none of them are about the content of the video

naravara Mar 10, 2021 View on HN

I'd kill for YouTube to start recommending short videos again. All I get recommended now are 20 minutes worth of content on something interesting stretched out to an hour long video. The recommendation algorithm seems to prioritize longer-form content, but the result has been creators being pushed to streeeeeetch and that usually means not editing down stuff that ought to be edited out.

IanCal Apr 9, 2015 View on HN

Indeed, I would expect it's viewing duration, otherwise we'd see 20 hour videos with 1 minute of content.

asimpletune Nov 28, 2021 View on HN

It’s probably because his videos are short so the algo doesn’t like them

aequitas Feb 23, 2024 View on HN

This is what youtube shorts should be, not those cutouts from 10 minute video's that stop just 3 seconds to early.

robmao Aug 4, 2025 View on HN

Short form video feed waste our time by design.

wingerlang Jan 22, 2019 View on HN

It's likely stretched to be juuuust above 10 minutes so that it can be (better?) monetized. I've more or less stopped watching videos of that length due to this.

scohesc Aug 18, 2023 View on HN

That's the most frustrating part for me with Tiktok, Youtube shorts, instagram etc.I wish you could scrobble through a video - it's more frustrating on Youtube because you always could and now all of a sudden you can't, and now videos 60 seconds or less get auto-converted into shorts (from what I've understood). Very annoying.Whoever designed this knew what they were doing on an addictions/product/customer retainment level because it sure wasn't a usabili

swyx Feb 15, 2025 View on HN

does it? i get pushed so many shorts and 15 minute video essays