US Doctors' High Pay

The cluster focuses on criticisms of high doctor salaries in the US healthcare system, profit-driven incentives, billing pressures, and comparisons to other countries, debating their impact on costs and patient care.

📉 Falling 0.4x Health
4,410
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4934
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
8
2008
19
2009
46
2010
48
2011
60
2012
76
2013
151
2014
143
2015
113
2016
204
2017
419
2018
331
2019
423
2020
311
2021
382
2022
395
2023
507
2024
410
2025
341
2026
23

Keywords

US M.R OPEC BS i.e academic.oup UK COL MD AMA doctors doctor medical patient physicians healthcare pay health care md

Sample Comments

pastor_elm Aug 16, 2018 View on HN

why would doctors willingly give up making extra hundreds of thousands of dollars?

petilon Oct 8, 2022 View on HN

You can't speak for other countries, but you can for all of the US? Then explain these articles:"Doctors Under Pressure to Meet Quotas and Fill Hospital Beds" [1]."Once hospitals have made such a huge investment, experts like Dr. Zietman say, doctors will be under pressure to guide patients toward proton therapy when a less costly alternative might suffice." [2]"While payments vary widely, doctors often collect $500 to $700 for a typical M.R.I. done on an o

8note Dec 7, 2024 View on HN

i wouldnt be surprised if doctors hared him for not making them the most profit possible, rather than anything about the sick and needy.

nradov Apr 14, 2024 View on HN

Your expectations are unreasonable. The medical system is extremely expensive to operate. Highly paid physicians should be reserved for delivering the most complex care.If consumers need guidance on making healthier lifestyle choices then doctors aren't even the best source. Utilize cheaper professionals for that stuff: therapists, counselors, social workers, dieticians, personal trainers, etc.

travisp Jan 18, 2021 View on HN

It's true that US doctors are paid more (although the gap isn't as big as it used to be). However, pay for US doctors makes up a fairly small portion of overall US medical expenditures (less than 10%). So, you could ask every doctor to work for free and not significantly change costs.

lurking15 Oct 28, 2024 View on HN

I don't disagree per se, but it seems from reading the article that they're bemoaning the shortage of qualified doctors and how they're all spent cause they have to work within the confines of centrally planned subsidy prices.Really they should be charging as high as possible directly to consumers until doctors are attracted into the profession. Cut out the middleman, there is no reason that routine expenses like a sick visit that gets routine labwork or medication need to be i

nickff Aug 10, 2020 View on HN

There's a reason doctors drive nice cars and wear nice shoes; they are collecting monopoly rents. The doctors and nurses are the ones extracting the vast majority of the wealth from the ever-growing healthcare sector. The problem is that saying we want more, lower-quality doctors, and cheaper foreign ones to improve services and reduce our expenditures is politically unpopular.

danieltillett Sep 14, 2018 View on HN

What a surprise - it is easier to get doctors to do things that increase billing than it is to get them to stop doing something if it decreases billing. It is almost as if money is more important than the patient.

entee Jun 20, 2018 View on HN

Another (darker) perspective: they don’t want to lose money. Healthcare in the US is expensive in no small part because we pay more for things (duh). One of those things is physician time. Primary care physicians in the US make $60K more a year than comparable nations [1].Dirty secret of healthcare: “efficiency” translates to “I make less money” for almost everyone in the system, very much including doctors. All will protest and justify their cost, all will make good arguments in the individu

ild May 24, 2015 View on HN

These doctors are not working for free, are they?