Effecting Political Change

The cluster discusses frustration with the ineffectiveness of individual actions like voting and protesting to influence politicians and society, advocating for organization, direct action, mass movements, and political engagement as better paths to real change.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Politics & Society
3,802
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4873
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
7
2009
18
2010
39
2011
73
2012
102
2013
320
2014
177
2015
172
2016
165
2017
224
2018
216
2019
317
2020
351
2021
385
2022
268
2023
326
2024
228
2025
358
2026
58

Keywords

e.g VIP WE US EFF OP nbcnews.com AG TSA youtube.com change voting influence want change political power protesting enact public opinion truth

Sample Comments

charlex815 Jun 20, 2018 View on HN

Politicians are more often mirrors of society than agents of change. Demand change from them, they aren't reading Hacker News. If they refuse change, campaign against them.

raquo Dec 2, 2017 View on HN

Feedback loop is way too long and way too uncertain for people to care. What can you even do to visibly affect decisions being made? There is nothing an individual person can do, because no one in power cares about individual people, whether they go picket or post to facebook.There are tens of millions of people in the US that really want to change, for a lot of . However, without acting as a unified group they don't matter because they're dwarfed by equally disor

helenakyso Jun 27, 2019 View on HN

Any ideas of What, WE, the individuals can do to make politician and countries change?

Probably not through voting. But direct action can get you to a better reality.

zo1 Aug 14, 2021 View on HN

Could also be the absolute futility that "contact your representative" represents now? I think more and more people are realizing that change can't happen that way anymore, particularly as you can't even organize grass roots movements without media and social-media approval these days. The only things that can get critical mass now to enact change from a citizen perspective are popular causes that are essentially "approved". Good to guard against bad movements like

solid_fuel Oct 3, 2025 View on HN

I won't be dismissing it with a trite line like "the world keeps spinning", for a start. Secondly, I am politically active and engaged, which is the most effective way to effect change right now.Encouraging others to actually engage with politics instead of being dismissive, with the goal to build a coalition of people who want to protect our rights against this consolidating dictatorship.You want to do something about it? Call your senator and voice your opinion.Your s

I generally agree, and want to add that you are not powerless. You can band together with others and then create political wind for the change(s) you desire. Many (most? all?) important changes in society were the direct result of people organizing and campaigning. It is an uphill battle which can be rewarding, interesting, very social, and: successful. :-)

idle_zealot Nov 5, 2025 View on HN

And advocating for mass individual consistent behavioral change is less than useless. If you want change you need political organization. The sum of public opinion is more influenceable than the sum of everyone's actions. Unfortunately, in the US it's not so simple as "vote for the party that's against this" as we only have two and neither are. Which means if you want to be effective you should throw your lot in with an advocacy group. In this case probably the EFF, mayb

kiliantics Mar 27, 2023 View on HN

This is the best answer. Voting and consuming differently are not impactful enough. Only mass labour movements will get the wheels turning. The proof is all there in recent history.

bell-cot May 19, 2023 View on HN

Step 1 - realize that the real world is not a happy-ending Orson Scott Card novel, where a smart-enough character (with no fame, power, nor wealth) has a realistic chance of becoming a VIP through online agitation. Let alone swaying substantial corporate and government decisions, based just on online fame.Step 2 - understand that those in power seldom care much about following any nice-sounding rules which they've published, when it is more comfortable & convenient for them t