Day Trading Debate

The cluster centers on debates about whether day trading and speculative trading are profitable or just gambling, with skepticism about scalability, high risks, and most participants losing money, contrasted by claims and anecdotes of successful traders.

📉 Falling 0.4x Finance & Crypto
4,185
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4869
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
9
2008
42
2009
77
2010
120
2011
87
2012
121
2013
165
2014
170
2015
180
2016
254
2017
320
2018
317
2019
328
2020
403
2021
480
2022
387
2023
263
2024
221
2025
226
2026
15

Keywords

NQ US gekko.wizb bitcointalk.org IDE index.php VIX HN BusinessWeek PFOF trading trades traders money trade gambling profit trader lose make money

Sample Comments

colesantiago • Mar 1, 2024 • View on HN

You're not missing out, this is just gambling, most people lose their money trading, easy money easy to lose, you can safely ignore them.

nemomarx • Aug 6, 2025 • View on HN

if you could make that much money day trading wouldn't it be scale able and someone else would already make those trades?

UK-AL • Dec 4, 2024 • View on HN

If you think trades don't kill you... you're naive

ricardobeat • Apr 30, 2013 • View on HN

Trading your time for money doesn't scale. Trade others'

photorized • Sep 3, 2012 • View on HN

Try hanging out with Wall St traders some time. That will put things in perspective.

shortrounddev • Apr 4, 2023 • View on HN

Day trading is not investing, it is gambling

exdsq • Jan 15, 2022 • View on HN

Sounds like regular day trading has similar issues too?

rrdharan • Dec 17, 2022 • View on HN

Trading requires this, but pure long-$coin speculation does not.

paulpauper • Aug 21, 2021 • View on HN

Typically there is more money to be made selling subscriptions than trading unless u are a major hedge fund. Desperate ppl look for any sort of guidance even if it does not work well.

bluGill • Sep 12, 2020 • View on HN

True, to make money you need a ton. Sometimes you will make bad trades. Even when it works out your gross profit on the 10000 trade is 100, out of which you need to pay expenses. It isn't a place for small players, but the amount of money on an individual trade isn't much.