American Exceptionalism

The cluster centers on discussions and critiques of American exceptionalism, the belief that the US is uniquely superior, leading Americans to overlook domestic issues, assume global representation, or deny problems seen elsewhere.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Politics & Society
4,471
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4861
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
9
2008
22
2009
36
2010
64
2011
56
2012
80
2013
249
2014
100
2015
143
2016
229
2017
262
2018
257
2019
308
2020
449
2021
468
2022
433
2023
391
2024
306
2025
549
2026
64

Keywords

US A.N LIVID USA ALL NYC wikipedia.org americans american america countries country nation problems earth nationalism interesting know

Sample Comments

unclebucknasty Jan 31, 2014 View on HN

It's a side effect of American Exceptionalism.

ossobuco Jan 13, 2025 View on HN

Typical run of the mill USAer mindset. Ah yes, we are "better" than them, so our problems don't really exist.

hestipod Jul 30, 2019 View on HN

Speaking as an American who has lived in other countries, the idea of "American Exceptionalism" is rampant in the USA and you will not undo it with any appeal or facts. It's built into the identity of so many people here. Seeing that as a group Americans are a majority on most English speaking websites, criticism, however correct, is always met with egoistic backlash. I hope you haven't taken it personally, nor believe that it's ALL of us. Nationalism is a disease, but o

ionised Feb 8, 2017 View on HN

this is what people are thinking about when they refer to 'American exceptionalism'.You can't seriously believe this?

bilbo0s Aug 28, 2024 View on HN

I'd say you two are pretty much like most Americans. ie - You readily identify the problems endemic to all the other Americans.I do it too. It's the way we're socialized here in the US via everything from the media and music to political speeches.What would be really interesting to know is if either of you are non-American? I have a sense that this proclivity might not be simply an American thing. I've wondered more and more if it's just human?

godelski Sep 15, 2019 View on HN

I think what's happening here is a difference in how we view our governments.In the West, and especially in America, we don't highly internalize "being American" (insert country). A lot of us just think of it as a circumstances. And right now there's a lot of distaste for what the government does. You'll probably find that most of the people are upset at their own country about exactly what you're upset about what America does (I know I am, and it looks like

drabiega Jul 12, 2016 View on HN

I've seen plenty of this mindset in America already and honestly they're not wrong.

azinman2 Jul 6, 2021 View on HN

A very American trait is to assume something is very American and doesn't apply elsewhere. Usually 'elsewhere' is just defined as a shallow understanding of Europe.

JabavuAdams Mar 7, 2017 View on HN

Technically, the writer did use the term "majority". That's not really the point though.There's this obnoxious US attitude that is really wide spread in the population that the US is the best, and that Americans are noble, even though they mess up occasionally.It's to the point where even when criticizing their own country, Americans will write that the criticism is in the spirit of improving the greatest nation on Earth, etc.It's just a really noticeable a

freshhawk Jun 1, 2012 View on HN

Not when you honestly believe in American Exceptionalism