Google Semantic Search Shift

Users debate Google's evolution from exact keyword matching to semantic understanding and recommendations, frustrating power users with niche queries while aiding casual users with natural language input.

📉 Falling 0.4x AI & Machine Learning
4,019
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4456
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
23
2008
56
2009
136
2010
178
2011
194
2012
158
2013
162
2014
109
2015
88
2016
125
2017
138
2018
166
2019
269
2020
244
2021
261
2022
484
2023
496
2024
325
2025
392
2026
15

Keywords

SEO e.g AI FAIL AskJeeves example.com wired.com exmaple.com index.php i.e search google query queries searches search engine searching engine results search engines

Sample Comments

account42 Jul 29, 2021 View on HN

In general, google no longer primarily searches what you asked them but for what they think you want. This might be better for the average user but can be extremely frustrating when you are trying to find something more niche.

pb7 Sep 25, 2020 View on HN

Consider that the vast majority of users are not like you and they need help using the right search terms. Searching used to be an art and I vividly recall a lot of folks struggle to articulate in search query terms what they were looking for. Nowadays those types of people find what they're looking for at the cost of you not being able to treat it like a command line interface. I'm sure Google has the data to back up that it's a net gain. You're welcome to use whatever you&#

marginalia_nu Sep 20, 2021 View on HN

Yeah, that's just not a type of query my search engine is particularly good at. It's pretty dumb, and just tries to match as much of the webpage against the query as it can.This used to be how all search engines worked, but I guess people have been taught by google that they should ask questions now, instead of search for terms.I wonder how I can guide people to make more suitable queries. Maybe I should just make it look less like google.

xbmcuser Aug 12, 2021 View on HN

no you are an edge case the rest of the world ie non tech users prefer the way google understands the queries and answers them.

arketyp Feb 15, 2022 View on HN

This is very helpful if I search for a name I didn't quite pick up or don't know how to spell, or if I only remember fragments of a quote or topic, then I just blurt out my stream of consciousness and Google will mostly point me in the right direction. That being said, I wish I could explicitly tell Google to treat my query more literally. Ideally you would be able specify the search query in some kind of grammar. They have these kinds of prompt mechanics for GPT3, so I doesn't se

marliechiller Jun 5, 2025 View on HN

Is there? I feel like google has optimised heavily for the caveman input rather than the enlightened search warrior nowadays

cup-of-tea Jun 30, 2018 View on HN

Learn to use a search engine. Why did this become a lost skill? You can tell it exactly what you want it to find using quotes or explicitly stating a locality.

enlyth Apr 12, 2020 View on HN

I would pay more than that for a version of Google which searches exactly for what I input like in the old days, and doesn't try to guess what I'm trying to search for with some nonsense NLP while ignoring half of my query

thoughtstheseus Jan 19, 2020 View on HN

The author is not using a "search" engine, Google is a recommendation engine.

zymhan Apr 20, 2020 View on HN

Because not everyone thinks in search operator keywords.