Autopilot Driver Attention

The cluster focuses on debates about the need for constant driver vigilance and readiness to intervene when using semi-autonomous systems like Tesla's Autopilot, questioning their safety, true autonomy level, and risks of driver inattention.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.3x AI & Machine Learning
4,976
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4261
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2009
2
2010
16
2011
28
2012
47
2013
31
2014
100
2015
143
2016
509
2017
299
2018
777
2019
467
2020
384
2021
621
2022
453
2023
466
2024
356
2025
251
2026
29

Keywords

SUV e.g AI IMHO FSD SAE L2 wikipedia.org ME autopilot driver driving car self driving attention pilot wheel self human

Sample Comments

ummonk β€’ Sep 29, 2020 β€’ View on HN

It's not the car driving itself if you need to be constantly attentive and ready to override it.

ehvatum β€’ Mar 14, 2021 β€’ View on HN

Driving with autopilot off certainly requires driver attention.

acqq β€’ May 27, 2016 β€’ View on HN

Yes the link should be replaced with yours.I believe that the autopilot that you have to override in critical moment is worse than the driving assistance that doesn't turn on until it's critical.In the former case, if you turn on the autopilot that you know is not just keeping the speed constant, you will tend not to be fully concentrated on the road all the time. And you'll surely seldom be able to estimate when the autopilot will work and when it won't.In the later

c3534l β€’ Sep 5, 2019 β€’ View on HN

The best way to stay attentive behind the wheel is to actually be the one driving. There's virtually no way of being both attentive and passive for long periods of time. If a driver can't check their email or whatever on their phone while autopilot is on, then autopilot is not safe to put in cars. And while I'm okay with not-exactly-safe for most things people willingly consume or use, driving is not an area where it's okay to roll out a feature that may cause people to stop

wyldfire β€’ Jan 5, 2017 β€’ View on HN

You're right, it should probably be a bit more muted. Perhaps "When enabled, [significantly less] driver attention is required." The driver can't go to sleep, for example, lest they miss the alert that indicates "oh no I can't figure it out anymore." Though the car would likely be designed to timeout on driver response and execute a safe deceleration/pull-aside maneuver.

Justsignedup β€’ Dec 14, 2022 β€’ View on HN

Humans are notoriously bad at just paying attention and not being in charge. Those few seconds their actual attention is needed are critical.I do appreciate that my car can do full distance control and assist if I am drifting, but it doesn't control itself, so I can never disengage. Personally I feel that this is wonderful and should be the limit. Anything past that should just be fully autonomous. Otherwise you're asking for trouble.

FormerBandmate β€’ Jun 10, 2023 β€’ View on HN

From what it sounds like, when you are in a traffic jam you use it and then the second that traffic jam ends you immediately have to take control.Ngl that sounds like it requires more attention than autopilot, if you’re not doing anything and then have to take full control that sounds like it could lead to an absurdly unsafe outcome

danmaz74 β€’ Apr 5, 2018 β€’ View on HN

It you have to pay attention as much as if you were driving, then, what's the point of autopilot?

Angostura β€’ May 3, 2024 β€’ View on HN

It feels to me like an autopilot problem in the making. "This thing means that you don't have to keep your eyes on the road - but please ensure you keep your eyes on the road, in case of errors"

tifik β€’ Nov 15, 2024 β€’ View on HN

Or it's the drivers are not "focused, alert", because of the auto-pilot.