LTO Tape Storage

Discussions debate the cost, density, reliability, and practicality of LTO tapes and drives versus hard drives for archival and long-term data storage.

📉 Falling 0.4x Hardware
2,241
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4222
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
1
2009
16
2010
12
2011
36
2012
75
2013
17
2014
104
2015
65
2016
52
2017
101
2018
110
2019
176
2020
205
2021
306
2022
204
2023
355
2024
181
2025
209
2026
15

Keywords

e.g SUSE LTO HDD QIC GB BluRays PERIOD MB THE tape lto tapes drives tb drive disk storage hard drives data

Sample Comments

adrian_b Nov 27, 2025 View on HN

You can buy a tabletop LTO tape drive, a SAS HBA card and an appropriate cable and you can use them with any desktop computer with a free big enough PCIe slot.The problem is that while the tapes are at least 3 times cheaper than HDDs, and you have other additional advantages, e.g. much higher sequential reading/writing speed and much longer storage lifetime of the tape, the tape drives are extremely expensive, at a few thousand $, usually above $3k.You can find tape drives for obsolet

tomjen3 May 15, 2021 View on HN

To clarify. a tape reader is about 5k, a tape is cheaper than a hard drive at the same storage capacity and can be stored for a long time without issue.

PaulHoule Sep 19, 2020 View on HN

Tape is a scam. PERIOD.I see LTO-8 drives sell for $3500 or so. LTO-8 tapes seem to be selling for about $120 or so today (although I couldn't find them a year ago back when a patent war was keeping them off the market)The LTO-8 tape has 12 TB capacity. I see 12TB hard drives selling for $270. You save $150 using a tape instead of a hard drive, so you have to replace 23 disks with tapes to make back the cost of the drive, or a total of 276 GB of storage.My experience is that

rbanffy Jun 14, 2025 View on HN

I'm surprised it's not LTO tapes. They are at least twice as dense as HDDs, lighter, and cheaper, and, for something like this, all you need is sequential access.

adrian_b Dec 12, 2022 View on HN

The LTO tapes are dirt cheap.Only the tape drives are extremely expensive (thousands of $).If you have hundreds of TB of data, LTO, including the cost of the drive, becomes cheaper than HDDs.The QIC tape cartridges had the problem that the rubber belt which moves the tape disintegrates after a number of years, making them unreadable without special equipment.The LTO tapes have a much longer lifetime.

adrian_b Jun 11, 2021 View on HN

There are at least 2 manufacturers for tapes (Fujifilm and Sony), but their tapes are also sold under many other brands (e.g. IBM, Quantum, HP).The price per TB is currently about $7 or less (per real TB of LTO-8, not per marketing compressed TB), so there is no chance to approach the cost and reliability of tapes using HDDs.The problem with tapes is that currently the tape drives are very expensive, because their market is small, so you need to store a lot of data before the difference in

sacnoradhq Jun 11, 2023 View on HN

Why? Hard drives are as cheap as tape now: $10/TB. Tapes are sequential access media, wear out, and malfunction, whereas hard drives are random access media. I know all about StorageTek silos and 4U tape robots but still don't bother with them.

anonu Apr 23, 2021 View on HN

Tape is still very cost effective. Load latency might be a few minutes though

dragontamer May 5, 2014 View on HN

The true cost of tape is that of the tape drive.Tapes themselves are pretty darn cheap. LTO-5 tapes cost $25 for 1.5TB (uncompressed). Multi-layer Blu-Ray is the only solution that is anywhere close to that cheap... but those are a pain-in-the-ass to use. (You'll need Thirty 50GB Blu-Rays to do the job of a single LTO-5 tape)Also consider: At x8, BluRays are written at 36 MB/s. Tape Drives are read/written to at 140MB/s, making them much faster than BluRays.The probl

adrian_b Jun 11, 2023 View on HN

Tape is $5 per TB at retail and you can safely store data on it for at least 10 years, after which you may need to make a new copy not due to the risk of aging, but due to the risk of no longer finding new tape drives compatible with the tape format.Your price of $10/TB might apply when HDDs are purchased in bulk, because at retail I see prices between $15/TB and $20/TB.No HDD may be trusted to store data for more than 5 years and this duration is valid only for the more exp