Car Repair Challenges

Comments focus on difficulties in repairing cars, including high parts costs, limited spare availability, warranty issues, dealership practices, and manufacturers restricting independent repairs like BMW bricking used parts.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.4x Hardware
3,856
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4085
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
1
2009
24
2010
23
2011
20
2012
95
2013
66
2014
53
2015
96
2016
204
2017
170
2018
269
2019
372
2020
242
2021
431
2022
464
2023
550
2024
392
2025
362
2026
24

Keywords

VW S63 UX ML320 BMW LS ML ID MBZ C1500 parts car repair cars repairs brakes mechanic replacement spare independent

Sample Comments

olliej β€’ Aug 9, 2022 β€’ View on HN

I feel like the analogy to a car requiring potentially expensive work/replacement parts isn’t reasonable, as you only have to replace those parts when they actually die, not at some random fixed point (as much as dealer-workshops may try to convince you otherwise)

Veserv β€’ Jun 1, 2024 β€’ View on HN

Because it is under warranty. As in, they are legally required to repair, replace, or, failing that, refund in full if there are any defects. A lack of spare parts to fulfill their legal obligation to provide a functioning product means they must either manufacture new spare parts at spot-price, provide a complete vehicle replacement, or issue a full refund. Each of these is massively more expensive than producing adequate spare parts up-front at bulk pricing.

ColonelBlimp β€’ Nov 28, 2022 β€’ View on HN

True. And when they break it's much more likely to find spare parts or someone who knows how to fix the car.

mtreis86 β€’ Jan 24, 2019 β€’ View on HN

You go in to the dealership because your three year old car needs repairs. They tell you its going to need a new engine and suspension and going to cost almost as much as a new car, and try to sell you on one instead of the repair. Mechanic down the street replaces your shocks and an intake manifold gasket for less than a tenth the cost of the dealer repair quote.

ranguski β€’ Sep 9, 2021 β€’ View on HN

What do you expect,with high repairablity, high costing of parts. Lack of transparent service. And junk boxes for cars? You'd need to run.

jjeaff β€’ Oct 26, 2018 β€’ View on HN

There are very few mechanics who will actually fix parts unless it is for their own vehicle. Most will just quite the price with a replacement part and move on. Even those that know how to do stuff like this rarely will agree to actually repair anything.

tcoff91 β€’ Nov 30, 2018 β€’ View on HN

Completely agreed. Unfortunately when you have to see the same mechanics who also work on Porsche, Mercedes, Audi, and BMW, you get reamed on the repairs. parts are expensive too.

function_seven β€’ Dec 26, 2025 β€’ View on HN

"Lemon" was never mentioned. That's extreme. I don't care what make and model of car you choose, I'll show you a list of TSBs associated with that model. There's never been a car produced that was perfectly engineered and had no after-sale issues common to that model and year. There's always something.Yes, I would be thrilled to find a car that gave cheap and available replacement parts so I could remedy those issues later. That used to be the standard! The

penjelly β€’ Aug 14, 2023 β€’ View on HN

the most insane examples ive heard of are the parts are ID'd so you cant swap out generic parts for even tiny repairs, the os will warn you youre using unregistered parts and prevent use

jsiaajdsdaa β€’ Feb 23, 2022 β€’ View on HN

Buy a car from a company that makes their items easy to repair.