Library Book Discarding

Discussions focus on libraries pulping, selling, or discarding old and donated books due to space constraints, with users sharing experiences, expressing sadness, and suggesting alternatives like public bookshelves, reselling, or personal sharing.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
2,494
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#4012
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
7
2008
10
2009
26
2010
98
2011
93
2012
94
2013
92
2014
65
2015
72
2016
80
2017
119
2018
160
2019
192
2020
198
2021
210
2022
350
2023
228
2024
162
2025
229
2026
9

Keywords

US UK BOOKS E.g wikipedia.org Z80 books book shelves library libraries condition donate second hand valuable donations

Sample Comments

Amezarak β€’ Dec 18, 2022 β€’ View on HN

Libraries are pulping old books en mass. Your donations might go to a sale. If they don’t sell they will be destroyed.

JoeAltmaier β€’ Jan 30, 2018 β€’ View on HN

There's a library book shop where they flog the outgoing volumes. They either get sold in a month, or burned. Since I was the only one checking out that venerable tome, it's probably been burned.

lazyjones β€’ Feb 11, 2013 β€’ View on HN

Throwing away books is sad... Don't you have any public bookshelves (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_bookcase) nearby?

yorwba β€’ Nov 5, 2025 β€’ View on HN

Most libraries probably don't stock many books like that. They'd just waste shelf space until they get discarded in the end.

tjr β€’ Aug 30, 2013 β€’ View on HN

Looking to discard a bunch of paper books a few years ago, I discovered that local libraries often do not particularly want donations of books, and if they do, they have particular requirements of what they might want. E.g., if they accept anything at all, they might accept a novel in good condition, but probably not a first edition of "Just Java".

erkose β€’ Oct 2, 2013 β€’ View on HN

Books can be shared, traded, or resold.

op00to β€’ Mar 5, 2021 β€’ View on HN

No one is saying you need to throw out books, only that certain people decided not to sell them.

grey-area β€’ Aug 18, 2013 β€’ View on HN

Lend them to friends when they visit, give them to a charity shop - that way someone else will enjoy them too. Why would you need to get money for them?There's no need to throw a good book away, or leave it collecting dust on your shelves (which is close to the same thing). Most books nowadays won't last longer than a human lifetime due to the perfect binding and terrible paper, so you're not keeping them for posterity by hoarding them.

cevi β€’ Jun 20, 2017 β€’ View on HN

Why not donate them to a library?

loeg β€’ Nov 11, 2019 β€’ View on HN

Deposit-return system for books? (Though it has obvious drawbacks that might outweigh any positives.)