Death Penalty Debate

The cluster focuses on arguments for and against the death penalty, particularly the irreversibility of executing innocent people compared to life imprisonment, deterrence effectiveness, and moral concerns.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
3,162
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3893
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
2
2009
32
2010
63
2011
57
2012
55
2013
136
2014
99
2015
283
2016
406
2017
82
2018
158
2019
225
2020
114
2021
455
2022
205
2023
322
2024
334
2025
124
2026
9

Keywords

US reprieve.org DUI AND en.m reddit.com SO CTRL wikipedia.org death penalty death penalty innocent prison punishment innocent people executed undo wrongly

Sample Comments

Dudeman112 Oct 3, 2023 View on HN

>If the death penalty had been applied, there's no "undo" button.There's no "undo" button for wasting away for 40 years in prison eitherTo me it looks like a glitch of the human cognition to think that losing almost/everyone you love, being dropped into a vastly different world than you knew, having your financial and social prospects thrown in the trash, living in shitty conditions for decades, is oh so much better and moral than killing them

jackmott May 27, 2017 View on HN

death penalty is fine except if you find out later that you were wrong you can't undo it.

cyberax Apr 18, 2024 View on HN

Death penalty does not serve as a deterrent compared to life imprisonment. It also sometimes applied to innocent people.

aught May 16, 2022 View on HN

he didn’t say execute them prison time is a much more effective incentive for cases resulting in death

posterboy Oct 19, 2017 View on HN

like what, the still up and going death penalty? doesn't get much more severe than that.

thfuran Jan 26, 2024 View on HN

Does that work without death penalty being on the table?

ddevault Feb 2, 2023 View on HN

The problem is that you cannot ascertain with certainty that someone is, in fact, a murderer. Countries with the death penalty will always execute innocent people. Roughly 5% of convicted persons are estimated to be innocent, and an execution makes the possibility of appeal or exoneration moot. At least 190 people in the United States have been sentenced to death and were later found to be innocent.

pyre Nov 21, 2011 View on HN

I'm thinking point is that with a death sentence, there is a possibility that something will exonerate the person before they die in prison. If the person is sentenced to immediate death, there are no do-overs. If we find out that an innocent person was executed, who get the blame? No one.

jsjohns2 Nov 1, 2016 View on HN

The lack of an "undo" button is not exclusive to the death penalty, many serious forms of punishment are irreversible.Why, in your view, is it much worse for the state to jail an innocent person for a long time (say, their entire adult life) instead of killing them?

SliceOfWaifu Apr 12, 2024 View on HN

Cause innocent people are sometimes wrongly convicted, and sentenced to death. Life behind bars without the possibility of parole achieves pretty much the same effect for public safety, while still giving the wrongly accused a chance to live. There are also rare cases in which new evidence overturns their conviction decades into their sentence. If they're put to death, they never get that chance.