Movie Ratings Debate

The cluster focuses on comparisons between movie rating systems like IMDB, Rotten Tomatoes, and Metacritic, debating the reliability of critic versus audience scores and their usefulness for recommendations.

📉 Falling 0.3x Other
2,371
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3733
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
21
2009
29
2010
58
2011
60
2012
153
2013
76
2014
132
2015
138
2016
101
2017
274
2018
96
2019
162
2020
128
2021
108
2022
299
2023
267
2024
118
2025
147
2026
3

Keywords

RT e.g II rottentomatoes.com III MUCH RottenTomatoes IMDB WAY tomatoes score rotten rating movies ratings critics critic movie audience

Sample Comments

IfOnlyYouKnew • Jun 4, 2019 • View on HN

IMDB is viewer ratings, not critics.

chrischen • Sep 8, 2017 • View on HN

Netflix personalizes rating scores (based on your ratings). Rotten tomatoes should implement that instead.

zoklet-enjoyer • Jan 16, 2024 • View on HN

Maybe they go by rotten tomatoes or imdb scores or it's just whoever runs the site's opinion and that's ok too

athriren • Nov 1, 2019 • View on HN

Does metacritic not work for this purpose for movies for you? It is what I use to do the things you list.

bufferoverflow • Aug 21, 2025 • View on HN

RottenTomatoes has been rotten for over a decade. IMDB user ratings are much more useful, but still far from perfect.

imbnwa • Apr 12, 2022 • View on HN

Are film critics losing sync with the average person who actually goes outta their way to rate movies on IMDB?

waxman • Mar 5, 2010 • View on HN

What does this do that Rotten Tomatoes doesn't do better?

omega3 • Jun 2, 2021 • View on HN

I find IMDB ratings are often over inflated, rotten tomatoes ratings are much better but not perfect.

forgot-my-pw • Jan 5, 2018 • View on HN

Rotten tomatoes just aggregates how likeable a movie is. A more accurate aggregate scoring system will be like metacritic.

gtirloni • May 27, 2020 • View on HN

If they could show the IMDB rating, it would be enough for me.