EU Schengen Free Movement

Discussions center on the distinctions between EU freedom of movement, Schengen border policies, and their implications for travel, work, and immigration, often comparing to UK, US states, and non-EU countries like Switzerland.

📉 Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
2,369
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3727
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
4
2008
1
2009
11
2010
29
2011
48
2012
35
2013
68
2014
83
2015
108
2016
282
2017
148
2018
168
2019
237
2020
179
2021
252
2022
167
2023
228
2024
156
2025
154
2026
11

Keywords

MITRE US OP ID EEA BSE UK U.K EU USMCA eu borders border movement switzerland uk country immigration europe countries

Sample Comments

sveme Apr 20, 2024 View on HN

They are part of the EU, so anyone from there can freely move and live there. You cannot restrict this. Limitations in flights would be feasible, I guess.

autoexec Oct 21, 2024 View on HN

No one in the EU has open borders. They have agreements with neighbors, much in the same way you can drive to a neighboring state in the US without much restriction, but interstate travel in the US and citizens of the EU going over the border for a holiday are very different from the situation we have with our southern border (and even with our northern border).

morpheuskafka Jan 15, 2019 View on HN

It's actually an artifact of the Schengen region not the EU itself. EU has freedom of movement rules, but Schengen provides for universal visa and lack of border controls. The UK (which is soon to be outside of the EU) has never been part of Schengen, but has and will continue to be part of the Common Travel Area which is the same thing but for UK and Irish Republic.

ghaff May 4, 2014 View on HN

>In a lot of Europe you would not know that you had crossed a border, it is no big deal. Even in and out of Switzerland that is not 'part of Europe' in the EU sense. It feels good when nobody cares to look at your passport and you can just roll on in.Well, that's because most of the EU (plus Switzerland and Norway) is part of the Schengen Area which explicitly allows for free movement between countries. I assure you that you can't just roll into the UK which is not unde

eptcyka Sep 30, 2021 View on HN

This isn't tenable in the EU due to the freedom of movement across borders.

aristidb Feb 9, 2014 View on HN

Schengen area is about border control. There definitely is free movement between the UK and other EU states, with exception only for criminals and such IIRC.

AdrianB1 Feb 20, 2023 View on HN

No, there is only a limited the freedom of travel between countries in EU (not Europe), but not of movement. For many years people from the newly admitted countries in EU had no right to work in the rest of EU. Most of the diplomas are not automatically valid in other countries and in some cases, not at all - example: pilot license for light planes, I have a Romanian license and I can fly in Greece a plane registered in Romania, but not a plane registered in Greece. If I switch to a Greek licens

Cryptonic Sep 27, 2021 View on HN

No need for visas between EU states. You can work wherever you want/must

eldaisfish Sep 2, 2025 View on HN

Legally, yes. Practically, the EU still has borders and barriers. Language, pension systems, degree equivalence, etc.Oh and also remember that the EU has freedom of movement for labour, not necessarily people. If you don’t have enough money, you can’t just move to another EU country and hope things work out.

paglia_s Jun 24, 2016 View on HN

That's false, Schengen only regulates border checks, EU citizens had the same right to move to the UK as UK citizens moving to a Schengen area country.