Government Power Critique

The cluster focuses on debates about the dangers of excessive government power, corruption, fallibility, and the need for reform or alternatives like decentralization, contrasting it with libertarian ideals or no government.

➡️ Stable 0.6x Politics & Society
4,343
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3716
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
12
2009
51
2010
92
2011
118
2012
98
2013
330
2014
120
2015
163
2016
245
2017
243
2018
250
2019
259
2020
322
2021
428
2022
425
2023
385
2024
284
2025
482
2026
33

Keywords

US WITHOUT EC government power governments western governance corrupt powerful evil society government government

Sample Comments

jokethrowaway Jan 26, 2021 View on HN

The government is made of people. It's inherently fallible and manages a lot of power. It's a recipe for disaster.We're at this intermediate stage because the previous solution was to just give all the power to a bunch of people, likely the ones that killed more people.Using elections instead of military power is an improvement over middle age, but you still have a bunch of people with a lot of power.There's absolutely zero trust possible.Maybe after western socia

_bxg1 Jun 18, 2019 View on HN

It's not hard to make the case that today's governments are tired and slipping and in need of reform. But there's no such thing as the libertarian fantasy of "lack" of governance. Human nature dictates that if there's a power vacuum, it will be filled. If it isn't filled carefully with a system designed to serve the people, it'll be filled by whoever can take it for themselves. And whether that's a feudal lord or Mark Zuckerberg, it will be wor

buro9 Jan 5, 2009 View on HN

Unfortunately I doubt it, the government is always in power.

aristofun Jan 11, 2026 View on HN

Isn’t the government a worst alternative?

phatskat Jul 9, 2023 View on HN

There isn’t any that I’m aware of - most governments fall victim to the rich and powerful, one way or another.

CamperBob2 Nov 10, 2023 View on HN

Maybe don't allow central governments to accumulate so much power.

sampa May 30, 2024 View on HN

you can't do anything.current governments in big/not-failed countries are way too powerful, so any idea that "people decide" is from an old age.they just want you to continue to believe this, so they keep the sheep and you think you live in a good ole western democracy, while you're not

dane-pgp Sep 24, 2021 View on HN

That's a bit like saying: "I don't mind giving my government absolute power, because my government isn't corrupt absolutely."

bserge May 30, 2021 View on HN

Me neither. The problem is the all powerful government that doesn't answer to the general population.It's great when they're doing what's best for the majority. But inevitably they start doing things for the powerful minority (themselves) at the expense of the rest.In a democratic system (which can, in fact, have heavy socialist elements) there are ways to legally and peacefully change the government. The public officials are servants of the people (well, ideally).In

beachstartup Jul 16, 2016 View on HN

well, it's a government, so it basically just works until it doesn't. then you get a revolution. and a new government, that works until it doesn't.nothing is guaranteed. it's just humans.