Vim vs Emacs Debate

Users discuss switching from Vim to Emacs, praising Emacs' extensibility, customization via Elisp, Org mode, and Evil mode for Vim emulation, while acknowledging Vim's modal editing strengths.

📉 Falling 0.4x Open Source
7,046
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3674
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
11
2008
135
2009
124
2010
228
2011
260
2012
211
2013
283
2014
371
2015
266
2016
536
2017
387
2018
450
2019
362
2020
757
2021
675
2022
517
2023
628
2024
398
2025
428
2026
19

Keywords

aaronbieber.com IMHO S3 lispniks.com youtube.com SSH IDE EDIT OT IMO emacs vim editor evil text editor lisp text mode editors modes

Sample Comments

skydhash Nov 2, 2024 View on HN

After years of VIM, I've decided to learn Emacs and have been doing all my coding and other stuff in it. There's not as much people and newer stuff like VSCode, but the whole ecosystem is pretty great and it's very extensible and customizable. Major and minor modes made is a good model to group functionalities together. Stuff like Compilation Mode, Tramps, Eglot, and how easy it is to add new features to the editor make it a joy to use.

combataircraft Mar 21, 2013 View on HN

Just Use Emacs. You have no idea what you are missing.

alex_smart Mar 11, 2021 View on HN

Vim user for 12 years, Emacs user for 5. I prefer and mainly use Emacs after I finally "got it". My previous attempts at learning Emacs weren't as successful because I was too biased about what a good editor should be like because of my familiarity with vim - mainly I was annoyed about silly things like having to press 4 keypresses for tasks that would take two keypresses in vim. So, if you decide to give Emacs a try, keep your preconceptions away and accept that it will take mont

jrsims Feb 19, 2008 View on HN

Can someone give me a reason to try emacs and leave my trusty vim?

lewaldman Dec 26, 2013 View on HN

Former VIm user... Current Emacs user.IMHO, Evil Mode makes to use emacs doable OTOH, the fact that there are so much extensions and possibilities under the hood makes to use emacs mandatory! :P

terhechte Dec 1, 2013 View on HN

I recently (about 6 months ago, I think) switched from Vim to Emacs + Evil (a really good Vim emulator) and the switch can only be described as awesome:I feel (and this may be just me) that Lisp in Emacs is easier to learn, better integrated, and offers more flexibility than VimScript in Vim. Thus, while my whole of custom VimScript over 5 years of usage can be reduced to around 20 lines in my vimrc, I've already written several small scripts, plugins, and more in emacs lisp since I star

turing_complete Sep 26, 2020 View on HN

I am using Vim. Is it worth it to try emacs?

hyperion2010 Jul 27, 2018 View on HN

I've been on vim for 8+ years. About 2 years ago I set up emacs because I wanted to start working in lisp land and use org mode. I couldn't use emacs without vim keybinds so I installed evil. I still use both editors, but I find emacs much easier to customize and the 'operating system' part of emacs makes it much easier to manage all the things I need to do. It sucks for big files, and there are some annoying quirks where repeating actions don't quite match vim's be

arnoooooo Mar 9, 2018 View on HN

I used Vim for 15 years, then switched to Emacs+Evil. Vim is the best interface, Emacs the best platform. Emacs+Evil combines both.

gcr Mar 29, 2013 View on HN

Someone has taught Emacs how to converse in the language of vim: http://gitorious.org/evil/pages/HomeBelieve it or not, Emacs is quite a fluent speaker. I was surprised to find that even esoteric things like rectangle selections work perfectly and :%s incrementally showing the results of your search and replace as you type is a hoot.Sure, emacs has its own accent and quirks, but after using emacs+evil as my only text editor