Job Offer Negotiation

Discussions center on strategies for handling job offers, including negotiating with competing offers, dealing with exploding offers, counteroffers, and whether to sign and renege.

📉 Falling 0.2x Career & Jobs
4,260
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3640
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
9
2008
35
2009
46
2010
104
2011
212
2012
174
2013
155
2014
283
2015
307
2016
371
2017
292
2018
214
2019
223
2020
215
2021
445
2022
496
2023
319
2024
199
2025
154
2026
7

Keywords

US IMO HN YMMV OK MSFT NO www.opm BEFORE EO offer offers job hiring freeze interview employer companies company position

Sample Comments

rm999 Jun 19, 2015 View on HN

Shoot to get another job offer. HR treats you much better when they know they have to compete for you - they'll speed up every step of the process, and they'll be more willing to negotiate. Also, you may end up liking the other offer more :)

jameshart Oct 13, 2017 View on HN

Absolutely - there’s a ton of implicit biases at work whenever you go down this path. Comes down to, if you want them to work for you, make them an honest offer and let them decide if it works for them. Companies obviously can’t put out multiple offers for the same position at a time, so there’s a natural tendency for companies to be careful with offers and only put them out if they are sure they’ll be accepted. But in this kind of case, if it’s an offer the candidate would reject out of hand, t

a_imho Feb 1, 2019 View on HN

It would be a very elaborate bluff to interview at another company, receive a bigger offer and not sign it.

albedoa Nov 29, 2017 View on HN

Yup, followed by "Oh you've received other offers? We'll see if we can accelerate the process on our end".No thanks, I'll just go with the existing offer from a company that doesn't hoist neon red flags during their interview process.

pacaro Mar 27, 2013 View on HN

This is the tough one that we all face, will asking them to move "slightly" cause you to lose the opportunity.Having been on the other side of the hiring process, I doubt it. Finding good candidates is hard, by the time that you are making an offer you are already much more invested in the candidate as a potential employee than you are in other candidates to whom you have not yet made an offer.But, (there's always a but!) if you are happy working there, and that's the result you wanted and

make3 Jan 6, 2018 View on HN

also, do you not ever tell a potential employer you have an offer from elsewhere, and to either offer more or you won't be in a position to accept their offer? if you don't, you should, it works.

xerophtye Feb 11, 2014 View on HN

Well, if I was the employer, i'd like my employees to come to me and tell me that they have better offers and discuss possible course of action BEFORE accepting any offers, rather than just accept the job and leave. This way if I want to make a counter offer, it gives me a chance to do it, otherwise I might admit I can't match the offer and wish him best of luck, no hard feelings.

good&important: No, job offers: Yes, better offers: Maybe

amenghra Jun 24, 2025 View on HN

Sign the first offer, continue interviewing, if you end up switching companies just write a nice email to your recruiter/manager explaining the situation. It wouldn’t be the first or last time that it’s happened.IANAL, the above isn’t legal advice, yada yada.

mrfusion Apr 14, 2016 View on HN

One place wouldn't give me an offer until I agreed to take the job.I assumed it was a hard sell tactic (and red flag) and declined.