Urban Homelessness Policies

Comments debate city measures to deter homelessness like hostile architecture and public transit restrictions, alongside discussions on shelter shortages, criminalization, and the need for housing and services.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
4,221
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3600
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
3
2009
20
2010
30
2011
18
2012
12
2013
118
2014
100
2015
68
2016
207
2017
201
2018
261
2019
593
2020
212
2021
581
2022
436
2023
619
2024
433
2025
305
2026
4

Keywords

US vimeo.com DC WiFi YouTube U.S MLK SC medium.com homeless homeless people shelter public sleeping city camping cities housing places

Sample Comments

MeinBlutIstBlau Nov 12, 2021 View on HN

Solves the problem of the people who wanted to minimize homelessness in their area didn't it?

eyelidlessness Sep 26, 2016 View on HN

Because try and stop a city from fucking over homeless people.

a-saleh Feb 18, 2016 View on HN

Sometimes I feel this "most of them prefer the way it is" is just a way to make excuses for us not solving a problem.For example in my city of ~ quarter mil. people, there are approximately 1000 people living on the streets and another 1000 without home (no adress, permanently living in hostels, people in prisons that no longer have home).Currently I know that there is project that focuses on the families without home (afaik 300-400 ppl?), where the plan is to move them into the

cameronbrown Aug 17, 2019 View on HN

My point was more about hostile architecture in general. I was trying to point out that the homeless have very few places to go - can't even shelter in a filthy public toilet. Anyone desperate enough to try has been stomped on enough without adding salt to the wound.The better solution is to try and fix the underlying cause rather than hiding the symptoms.

marcellus23 Sep 30, 2021 View on HN

People do that in my city too — they're homeless people who don't have anywhere else to go. The solution is to give them housing and jobs. Until that happens, I'm okay with them sleeping on the train if they need to.

themafia Nov 24, 2025 View on HN

Falling asleep on a bus is a great way to get victimized. The homeless are most likely to be victimized by other homeless. It almost never gets reported to the police.It's not a shelter and it's not meant to be converted into one. To me it's an indication of an overworked and failing system that leaves people in bad situations because it has nowhere else for them to go.Sure, you could argue that because there's currently no obvious major problems, that you could ju

whimsicalism Aug 2, 2025 View on HN

the homeless issue has caused cities to underprovision amenities like benches

dragonwriter Oct 7, 2016 View on HN

> Never seeing homeless people or people who don't look like you doesn't mean they aren't the or that there's not a problemIn fact, many jurisdictions have practices which inflict harm on the homeless specifically to make them less visible (and/or to cause them to relocate and become someone else's problem.)

nkoren Jul 26, 2017 View on HN

Thank you.Yes, apologies for building too many assumptions; I guess this is a bit of a hot-trigger issue for me. I've seen people genuinely believe that if one makes life sufficiently difficult for the homeless, they'll just go away. In London this has lead to appalling incidents like [1]. I thought that was where you were coming; I see now that it wasn't. Sorry again!In any case, I haven't got time to discuss this either -- gotta get back to work!1: <a href="http:&#

ocdtrekkie Jun 25, 2022 View on HN

This is like solving homelessness by putting spikes on benches to keep people from sleeping there: It doesn't solve the problem, it just pushes it out of your jurisdiction.