Murder Definition Debate

Commenters intensely debate the definition, legality, and moral equivalence of 'murder' in response to a hypothetical or specific scenario, often questioning if an act qualifies as murder or is merely a thought crime.

📉 Falling 0.4x Legal
3,281
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3335
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
2
2008
7
2009
31
2010
35
2011
27
2012
66
2013
151
2014
101
2015
141
2016
167
2017
204
2018
167
2019
245
2020
272
2021
420
2022
301
2023
349
2024
307
2025
254
2026
34

Keywords

US CEO TikTok murder crime murders exceptional prison kill gun killing murdered man

Sample Comments

MrMan • Nov 22, 2013 • View on HN

yeah man! murder is just a thought crime now.

ta2162 • Jun 28, 2021 • View on HN

What makes it "murder"?

skookumchuck • Oct 13, 2018 • View on HN

That's like saying "murder is proscribed only if you get caught".

Marazan • May 8, 2017 • View on HN

Errr because murder is a really serious crime?

googlryas • Nov 7, 2022 • View on HN

I bet you view murder as a negative.

rdtwo • Sep 1, 2022 • View on HN

Why can’t we just call it murder?

DanBC • Mar 1, 2019 • View on HN

It seems fair enough to say that literal murders are unacceptable.

superblas • May 15, 2025 • View on HN

Could you please expand on how that is murder?

theappsecguy • Jan 13, 2026 • View on HN

Not sure homicide fits into “small crime” category.

fsloth • Jun 22, 2019 • View on HN

A life saved is not sufficient to counter a murder.