German Deindustrialization Debate

Discussions center on Germany's manufacturing prowess, export success in high-precision industries, potential economic decline due to high energy costs, reliance on the car sector, and debates over deindustrialization risks versus ongoing strength.

📉 Falling 0.5x Politics & Society
4,430
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3259
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
4
2008
5
2009
15
2010
85
2011
114
2012
128
2013
99
2014
144
2015
205
2016
160
2017
279
2018
228
2019
298
2020
387
2021
402
2022
457
2023
536
2024
426
2025
423
2026
35

Keywords

II US GP NSA MONEY BASF wikipedia.org MAKE WORK ECONOMY germany german economy industry manufacturing car annual germans mark trains

Sample Comments

mathattack • Nov 23, 2013 • View on HN

This concept is very strange to me, as Germany is generally considered to be a high-efficiency high-wage country. I wonder if this comes from social pressure of supporting so many high-social-welfare countries.

mantas • Jan 17, 2024 • View on HN

More like „Germany tries to prevent de-industrialisation and economy collapse“.

mertbio • Nov 27, 2025 • View on HN

Germany doesn’t compete in cheap manufacturing, they compete in highly precise manufacturing. There are bunch of things that are only manufactured in Germany. You don’t hear those companies that much because they are not public but they are well known by the people who work in specific industries. When you combine them, they are way bigger than the German companies you hear everyday which are laying off people or closing factories.For some reason, every time Europe is mentioned, there is alwa

rdouble • Feb 20, 2011 • View on HN

Germany exports expensive stuff.

tonf • Oct 1, 2010 • View on HN

Germany would not be the second biggest exporter in the world if it was a myth. German approach seems to work better than English one at least in older, more established industries (cars, etc).

The_Colonel • Jan 11, 2024 • View on HN

This might be a hot take, but I think Germany is suffering from a sort of Dutch disease with its car industry.Germany has a lot of human capital, experienced and well educated workforce, but a lot of it got sucked into the car industry, because it was so profitable until now. I hope that with the car industry sunsetting, hopefully we'll see new innovative companies spring up.

emsy • Jul 24, 2018 • View on HN

Do you happen to live in Europe? I live in Germany and while the Silicon Valley mentality doesn’t look healthy or sane, Germany is surprisingly “lame” for such a successful country. The German economy relies too much on old industries and the politics here are unwilling to change anything about it, be it policies, funding or infrastructure.

Timon3 • Jul 5, 2023 • View on HN

"German Deindustrialization Is Still Looming" - so it hasn't actually begun?

jdthedisciple • Sep 5, 2021 • View on HN

Weird logic. You think Germany is not gonna profit massively - both monetarily as well as otherwise - already?

laydn • Sep 4, 2024 • View on HN

Seems like Germany is having this problem for the past 20 years... but here we are. Maybe accept the fact that they are a manufacturing powerhouse and will remain so in the foreseeable future?