Child Pornography Legality

Cluster debates the legality, ethics, and criminalization of possessing, viewing, distributing child pornography (CSAM), including arguments for decriminalization, censorship, and comparisons to other illegal content.

📉 Falling 0.4x Legal
5,831
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#3007
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
9
2009
80
2010
141
2011
108
2012
285
2013
337
2014
144
2015
202
2016
311
2017
313
2018
259
2019
547
2020
360
2021
794
2022
504
2023
583
2024
373
2025
413
2026
67

Keywords

OPA US www.ftm www.yo falkvinge.net stallman.org CSAM CGI FBI jun.html child pornography porn crime abuse pictures children harm sexual victims

Sample Comments

kragen Jun 18, 2024 View on HN

also child porn laws: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40712506

pimentel Mar 4, 2014 View on HN

Check http://falkvinge.net/2012/09/07/three-reasons-child-porn-mus... to think a bit more about the other side of the matter.

bdangubic Jan 1, 2025 View on HN

what about child pornography? that cool to as long as one doesn’t use it?

AndyKelley Jul 29, 2013 View on HN

Child porn is bits too. People seem to be okay with making those bits illegal.

TallGuyShort Jun 19, 2019 View on HN

I have never distributed child pornography or snuff films. I'm already not subjecting anyone to it. Communications channels exist. Unless you want to undo that, or enable this behavior, you have to deal with it somehow.

Lawtonfogle May 18, 2015 View on HN

What of the reddit sub that hosts pictures of dead children? What of videos of adults being sexually abused (not staged, actual abuse)? What of videos/images of other crimes that could cause emotional damage to those victims if the content were to spread? What of the abuse of the current laws to punish teens for engaging in what is quickly becoming normal behavior? What of the potential for the government to create systems to catch this one exception we make that we then once again find

cousin_it Jan 25, 2010 View on HN

In my opinion, downloading and looking at pictures of naked children shouldn't be a crime. Making child porn also shouldn't be a crime unless it falls under child abuse laws. For example, animated or CGI child porn should be legal because its production and consumption harms no one. (Currently it's illegal and people have gone to jail for it.) We stopped imprisoning and castrating homosexuals sometime ago, but apparently people can't internalize the too-abstract ideas of "victimless crime" and "

bandushrew Nov 24, 2011 View on HN

hmm? 'Rape' has auto suggestions.In general I dont think that consumption of child pornography is much of a crime, the harm has been done by then, and some poor sad git masturbating over a 3 year old isn't going to make it any worse.Personally I would rather they put significant resources into catching those people who create it, than into changing search engines and blocking dns addresses so that everyone can pretend it doesn't exist.

thefreeman Jul 17, 2015 View on HN

Do you really have a problem with that? They didnt make the porn. It's not like removing it would prevent it from being made in the first place. They were capturing information on additional pedophiles. In what world are you trying to frame that as wrong.

rmc Sep 10, 2012 View on HN

Drug prohibition is a different issue.Yes, there are cases of things which are not child porn in spirit, however its important to remember that there are things that are actual child porn. There are pictures of young children and toddlers and babies being raped. We don't see them in the mass media, because they are disgusting, but they exist. Don't forget that creating this pictures is probably one of the most horrific and harmful crimes in modern society.