Book Reading Debate

Users debate whether a specific book promoted in the thread is worth reading in full, critiquing its depth, quality, and value versus summaries or dismissing it as superficial or promotional.

📉 Falling 0.4x Other
6,673
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2977
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
36
2008
108
2009
151
2010
221
2011
205
2012
214
2013
268
2014
271
2015
276
2016
346
2017
343
2018
455
2019
528
2020
559
2021
577
2022
609
2023
577
2024
482
2025
428
2026
19

Keywords

SEO TOC OP GP HN amazon.com ycombinator.com book read read book reading book reading topic reference read read signal noise dragon

Sample Comments

pugworthy • Nov 26, 2019 • View on HN

Seriously, read the book. You're grossly misjudging what the book discusses.

nailer • Apr 27, 2019 • View on HN

Your post has no content. Saying "read this book" isn't a response - maybe summarise the point you want to make?

tptacek • Jun 16, 2018 • View on HN

That book does not appear to be well-regarded.

Vera527 • Sep 13, 2016 • View on HN

This is a freaking book, not an article. Who has time to read all of this?

JosephJoestar • Jun 3, 2019 • View on HN

Interesting topic but is this not just an advert for this guys book?

throwaway82729 • Aug 17, 2018 • View on HN

I agree with the GP. The book just went round and round on the same topic. You'll be better off reading a summary on Blinkist or elsewhere.

davidw • Oct 29, 2015 • View on HN

Book looks interesting - anyone else think it's worthwhile?

singularityyy • Mar 1, 2014 • View on HN

That reads like a highly un-objective view of the book, not trying to dissuade people from reading it though - I think it's a nice perspective

sesqu • Aug 27, 2014 • View on HN

Prior and subsequent to reading the book, I suggest you read some of the critique the book has recieved, as the topic is quite anecdotal.

GuiA • Dec 10, 2013 • View on HN

At least one person who is not the author seems to have liked this book, so I challenge the assumption that it "appears to be a bad book".And... it's a book, dude. You can check it out from the library or buy it used for ten bucks and stop reading it if you don't like it; that's not going to ruin your life. If you have enough time to reply to my dumb comments on HN, you must certainly have the time to start reading the book for 30 minutes and decide if it's worth