Evolutionary Mate Preferences

Comments debate evolutionary biology explanations for sex differences in human attraction, where men prioritize physical beauty and fertility cues while women emphasize status, resources, and selectivity.

📉 Falling 0.2x Science
2,761
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2919
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
13
2008
44
2009
117
2010
135
2011
72
2012
80
2013
86
2014
81
2015
94
2016
171
2017
214
2018
189
2019
248
2020
212
2021
217
2022
309
2023
238
2024
132
2025
106
2026
3

Keywords

BBC OP HN www.bbc ycombinator.com EG i.e www.pbs TLD wikipedia.org women men males females sexual sex evolutionary selection offspring mate

Sample Comments

zodiakzz Aug 25, 2021 View on HN

Females just have different/complex drives/needs for sexual attraction than males, who are mostly just drived by libido/horniness. You can observe this in nature too. Seems the males are the "abnormal" ones here, addicted to chemical reactions in the brain. (Didn't expect to see this line of thinking on HN...).

GhostVII May 14, 2018 View on HN

It makes more sense in nature for females to be more selective than males, since once they choose a mate they have to deal with that choice for a while, resulting in males competing for females. So I think it makes sense that men would naturally be competing for women, and would have to take more risks, and try and get more money/recognition, to do that.

toasterlovin Jan 31, 2019 View on HN

Female selection of males is a thing. If it weren't, the subject matter of most popular culture would not be roughly 80% romance and relationships.

jondubois Jan 31, 2016 View on HN

It's probably because of aesthetics. Humans are not birds; in our case, sexual selection applies to both genders.

nazgulnarsil Jun 27, 2009 View on HN

file this under "duh", men care about looks, women care more about status as a stand-in for fitness to provide offspring with resources.

taterbase Jul 1, 2012 View on HN

It's not "society" that's failed. It's basic natural instinct kicking in. Many men prefer wider hips, large breasts, and youthful appearance. We can say all day that this comes down to taste but your inner caveman knows that she will be a healthy and providing mother.

wyager Jan 26, 2023 View on HN

As with many sexually dimorphic behaviors in humans (and mammals in general), this flows from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variability_hypothesisYou can have a stable/growing population with only 1 male per n>1 females. So, the evolutionarily optimal strategy is to crank up trait variance in males and have females select only the top 1/n males (hand-wavily sp

willcipriano Mar 10, 2022 View on HN

It's almost entirely about secondary sex characteristics and those exist exclusively to find fertile mates. Gay people still look at their potential partners secondary sex characteristics when deciding to mate with them. It's sort of a distinction without a difference situation.

nashashmi Jul 22, 2023 View on HN

Men don’t communicate (as much).The rest of your hypothesis rests on an idea that women evolved (into a species?) with reinforced traits focusing on appearance. Disagree here Because Men and women didn’t evolve into different “species” And neither do we find similarities between them in this regard.Selection pressure is an idea that tries to explain the trends in evolution. It is just an idea. It would be careless to trace everything in current state of behaviors to evolutionary changes.<p

niuzeta Nov 20, 2017 View on HN

The article itself is saying that women's proclivity to want higher status male is due to biology. If we're okay with it, then shouldn't men's proclivity to want younger, healthier female be okay?