Social Media Age Restrictions

Comments debate imposing age limits or bans on children's access to social media, internet content, or porn, drawing parallels to regulations on alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs for minors.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Politics & Society
1,938
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2575
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
2
2009
4
2010
13
2011
22
2012
17
2013
48
2014
33
2015
40
2016
59
2017
54
2018
128
2019
250
2020
104
2021
182
2022
206
2023
245
2024
228
2025
256
2026
47

Keywords

TFA VP US LSD FDA wikipedia.org alcohol cigarettes adults kids tobacco children laws illegal drinking smoking

Sample Comments

EatingWithForks May 23, 2023 View on HN

It's also illegal to partake in cigarettes in certain areas, even for adults. Cigarette packaging and location is also regulated. It's not like adults have unfettered access to things that harm them. It's illegal to drink and drive. In some places, it's illegal to drink in public, or it's illegal to sell alcohol beyond certain time periods. I'm not saying that these things are right, but that if we're going to compare social media to harmful substances we shou

lakpan Mar 2, 2024 View on HN

What kind of question is this? If drugs are sold without limits, then children will also be affected.The right answer is that they would still need to be controlled just like cigarettes and alcohol.

thatusertwo Aug 28, 2012 View on HN

It could be biased, but children (less then 18) probably shouldn't be drinking, smoking or doing drugs anyways.

br121 Jan 15, 2026 View on HN

Cigarettes and alcohol are more strictly regulated for children than for adults, but are regulated for both, because adults are allowed to harm themselves, but there is a general agreement that the law should discourage that. Yet the call for a social media ban on children is (or at least that's my impression) never accompanied with proposed regulation for adults, or a stricter enforcement of already in place but unenforced rules. I totally agree with you on how the "we shouldn't

vanviegen Nov 1, 2021 View on HN

I'd say: no, they shouldn't be allowed to do that.In the same way kids aren't allowed to drink alcohol, smoke cigarettes or gamble. That shit's addictive, and we as a society don't expect children to be able to properly consider the long term consequences when making the decision to use it. (Of course one could make the same argument about adults, but I digress.)

squigz Mar 8, 2025 View on HN

Probably for the same reason we allow adults to smoke and drink but not children.

a4a4a4a4 Jan 5, 2023 View on HN

> By your logic should we allow kids to buy alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs because it inconveniences adults too much?By your logic, we should allow the government to search our phones, computers, cars, emails, etc before buying alcohol, cigarettes, and drugs because "it might save just one child!".

pixl97 May 23, 2023 View on HN

You mean like we made it illegal to sell cigarettes or pot (where it is legal) to children... whoa, it's almost like we can have laws limit stuff.

AlbertCory Jan 19, 2024 View on HN

Props for saying it.The kids would hate it, but then, they hate laws against selling tobacco & alcohol to minors and letting them into X-rated movies too. Too bad. It's for your own good, Junior."They'd just find ways around it" ?? Then we'll block those, too. We don't need to be 100% effective.

lemming Nov 23, 2025 View on HN

The same way that the law prevents kids drinking their parents’ alcohol - it doesn’t. But having it be illegal sends a signal, even though it’s possible to circumvent it, and also allows prosecution if warranted.