Brick-and-Mortar Decline

The cluster discusses the struggles of physical retail stores against online shopping giants like Amazon, including showrooming where customers browse in-store but buy online, leading to closures of bookstores, electronics shops, and others.

📉 Falling 0.4x Startups & Business
4,656
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2560
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
9
2008
30
2009
80
2010
107
2011
251
2012
274
2013
216
2014
170
2015
206
2016
128
2017
313
2018
357
2019
436
2020
487
2021
437
2022
331
2023
306
2024
236
2025
265
2026
17

Keywords

BN HelpPing Diapers.com HMV DVD MSRP DC BB DTC CVS stores store brick mortar mortar online amazon brick retail retailers buy

Sample Comments

aninteger Mar 16, 2022 View on HN

Retail stores should still be an option.

viridian Nov 8, 2017 View on HN

I think the synthesis is the hope that the market replacements for these stores is less terrible. The big displacer in the last few years has really been Amazon, who I think offers a better shopping experience than most overpriced specialty stores. Many of these stores only held firm in the market due to having an information advantage over the consumers, as well as the convenience of providing items that are similar in kind (ie toys at toys r us). The effects of a post online shopping and price

apolymath Mar 21, 2019 View on HN

Too bad retail stores are going the way of the dodo...

caffeine5150 Jun 11, 2012 View on HN

What's hurting the brick and mortar store is not the "going in to compare items" part, but rather it's the "buying on Amazon instead of from the local store" part. You may as well say, "If everyone bought online instead of at the store the stores would close."

toyg Aug 29, 2016 View on HN

Any brick&mortar in the age of the internet cannot compete on convenience, that's inevitable; but they can compete on atmosphere, community and discovery.Bookshops have much in common with record stores, and have disappeared at a similar rate under pressure from Amazon and ebooks. The few survivors don't fight on convenience: they stock very limited catalogue, but attract patrons with events, community-building, specialist focus and so on. In some cases, what was a bookshop wit

phobosdeimos Aug 23, 2018 View on HN

There was an electronics retailer in my country who did this. It worked great for a few decades but online shopping killed it.A website has unlimited shelf space, physical retail doesn't. And e commerce has now been pretty much perfected with free next day delivery and internet banking.

dzink Feb 16, 2020 View on HN

Storefronts are becoming the discovery location, while sales shift online. In the past few months I’ve had more than one staple household purchase disappear from grocery shelves to require us to buy from Amazon. It makes sense - stores now charge something like $250k for stocking/shelf space fees. Bookstores have a different structure, but I hope to see more online warehouses show up to rival Amazon, because scalpers do enjoy hiking prices there whenever something is out of stock elsewhere.

fitandfunction Feb 11, 2013 View on HN

Yeah -- It's definitely by design.It's also by design that milk and bread are in the back corners of the store.But, ecommerce makes this disdain for the shopper unsustainable. 10 years ago, if you're store sucks, you don't really have a choice. Now, if you're store sucks ... well I can buy a majority of the stuff I need through Amazon, Diapers.com, etc.So, could HelpPing be a timing play? Helping change stores right when they need to change ... so that they can survive to 2020?Thi

nunez Feb 2, 2023 View on HN

This is how brick and mortar stores work too; not unique to Amazon (except the dynamism of the storefront).

TallGuyShort Nov 8, 2017 View on HN

>> More informed purchases because people buy stuff online where it's easier to compare reviews.I was wondering about this forcing stores to provide more expertise and more flexible inventory. In my town 2 stores in a specific industry went out of business 3 years ago and made a big deal in the papers about how too many people were buying direct from manufacturers instead of visiting their store. I had been to both stores, asked some questions about products, got dumb answers and b