Race vs Ethnicity Debate

Comments debate the distinction between race and ethnicity, criticizing US categorizations like Hispanic as ethnicity rather than race, highlighting fuzzy boundaries, overlaps (e.g., white Hispanic), and lack of scientific basis.

📉 Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
2,753
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2545
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
5
2009
20
2010
44
2011
51
2012
27
2013
83
2014
100
2015
95
2016
170
2017
143
2018
182
2019
221
2020
234
2021
352
2022
353
2023
291
2024
150
2025
216
2026
16

Keywords

w.r US HN agree.I GTA AA MENA census.gov USA SE race hispanic white ethnicity black asian american americans races culture

Sample Comments

hnbad Jun 16, 2023 View on HN

Since race is not a scientifically meaningful concept, I assume you mean ethnicity?

dpoochieni Feb 20, 2021 View on HN

Thought these were all nationalities and not a single "race" as you call it

ibrahimsow1 Apr 29, 2022 View on HN

Race isn't a discrete category. Ethnicity is closer to what you're describing.

79a6ed87 Jan 11, 2023 View on HN

Or Hispanic/Latin being considered a separate race from White. Doesn't make any sense

socjus Apr 26, 2009 View on HN

It sounds as if you're no longer talking about race but ancestral nationality.

Retric Feb 20, 2009 View on HN

One problem is when someone in the USA is 75% white 25% black people label them black. It's not that ethnic groups don't share common traits it's just the borders are so fuzzy it's going to be hard to narrow down specifics.

IkmoIkmo Sep 16, 2015 View on HN

Neither is black or hispanic. The entire debate around 'race' in the US I find is riddled with outdated concepts and semantics. In many developed countries's dialogue on these issues the semantics rarely touch on race anymore as it's quite meaningless and scientifically untenable. Instead when we talk about different peoples in socioeconomic debates by referring to various ethnicities (which are quite flexible, you can group people on ethnic bases by culture, religion, langua

lmz Mar 28, 2019 View on HN

It's national origin based, not race based.

elboru Jan 17, 2019 View on HN

For me (a Hispanic) it's odd to see any race categorization at all, it seems like an obsession for both right and left wings in the US. Why does it matter so much? White and Hispanic is not mutually exclusive in a lot of cases, the same for Black and Hispanic or Native American and Hispanic, in most cases it's difficult to even set a race tag.

not2b Apr 1, 2022 View on HN

It isn't treated as a race in the US either, it's a separate question (so people can identify as white and Hispanic, or black and Hispanic, or other combinations).