Two-Party Sameness Debate

Comments debate whether US Democrats and Republicans are fundamentally similar or distinct, often critiquing 'both sides' arguments, partisanship, and the illusion of choice in the two-party system.

➡️ Stable 0.8x Politics & Society
4,547
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2498
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
8
2009
24
2010
50
2011
66
2012
72
2013
195
2014
104
2015
83
2016
209
2017
384
2018
247
2019
230
2020
511
2021
523
2022
461
2023
405
2024
311
2025
622
2026
42

Keywords

US api.rnc HN DJT GOP USA API U.S parties partisan party republicans democrats republican political democrat sides political parties

Sample Comments

maxxxxx Oct 27, 2011 View on HN

Please don't make this into another democrat vs republican issue. They may be using different language but both parties are essentially the same when it comes to the things they actually do.

nerdponx Mar 17, 2020 View on HN

More indication that the Democrats and Republicans are just a face/heel arrangement.

minikites Feb 16, 2018 View on HN

You're probably going to get downvoted because "both sides are the same" but they really aren't. Only one party is doing this.

refurb Apr 5, 2021 View on HN

It's being downvoted because it ignores the same issues on in the Republican party. Anyone who thinks either party is some monolithic blocks that all votes the same way hasn't been paying attention.

rgrieselhuber Jan 30, 2019 View on HN

It's helpful to look past the illusion of the two parties and realize that most of the politicians in each party are more on the same side in the big picture stuff than not.

metabagel Apr 19, 2020 View on HN

“ The Republicans and Democrats alike are guilty of such behavior.”This isn’t a useful line of thinking. We can and should draw distinctions between the two parties. They aren’t the same. Pretending they are just muddies the waters.

acdw Feb 20, 2021 View on HN

> Thinking that your "team" is the good guys and the other are the bad guys is exactly why politicians get away with this. There is nuance in the world.This is really annoying to me /because/ I'm a liberal -- I sometimes /wish/ the more liberal in Congress would be more of a "team," but they're just /not/.And it /really/ pisses me off when people both sides the current political climate, because you have -- on Republi

pastage Mar 14, 2025 View on HN

Everything is not partisan it might be political. The Republican vs. Democratic is hurting the US badly you can not continue to make everything ok just because you need the support from whatever extreme views is populist in your party.Most of the things a party does is not extreme but you guys are going insane over there.

abritinthebay Mar 29, 2017 View on HN

Given this vote was split along party lines this smells of whataboutism.

arca_vorago Mar 31, 2017 View on HN

Yes you are being partisan and not seeing how the D's do the same things. If I wasn't on mobile I'd explain more in detail, but essentially its a corruption, oligarchy, corporatacracy problem that transcends parties.