Unproven Theory Skepticism

Commenters repeatedly label a proposed idea as an unproven theory or hypothesis and demand evidence, data, or proof to support it.

📉 Falling 0.4x Science
4,285
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2470
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
9
2008
24
2009
54
2010
79
2011
87
2012
101
2013
150
2014
148
2015
169
2016
221
2017
240
2018
271
2019
261
2020
336
2021
476
2022
386
2023
494
2024
411
2025
349
2026
19

Keywords

GP I.E UPA MACHO McCarthy hypothesis theory interesting plausible intriguing theories hypotheses explanation data alternate

Sample Comments

tayistay • Oct 4, 2021 • View on HN

Ok plausible theory. Can you prove it?

skybrian • Feb 26, 2019 • View on HN

This sounds vaguely plausible, but do you have anything backing that up? Unproven theories are a dime a dozen.

steamy • Apr 22, 2015 • View on HN

A plausible theory, that's all!

hyperpallium • Jan 23, 2018 • View on HN

It's more an intriguing hypothesis than an accepted finding. The reasoning is interesting and plausible.

RickJWagner • Oct 23, 2019 • View on HN

An interesting theory, but there's no proof of it, is there?

frfl • Jan 12, 2024 • View on HN

Haven't come across this theory, but sure, it's a theory.

humanrebar • Sep 17, 2015 • View on HN

That's an interesting theory with absolutely no evidence to support it.

joelbluminator • Oct 7, 2020 • View on HN

Interesting theory. Let's agree that it's inconclusive then!

arcticbull • Jan 12, 2022 • View on HN

That's a cool theory, do you have any data to back it up or is this just an unfounded assertion?

22289d • Dec 18, 2022 • View on HN

That's an interesting hypothesis - though one that is far from fact, that many would disagree with, and which has never been tested. As such, you might want to avoid fallaciously stating it as a certainty.