Doomsday Predictions Skepticism

The cluster centers on skepticism toward apocalyptic predictions, particularly environmental and climate collapse scenarios, with commenters citing historical failed doomsdays like peak oil, population bomb, Y2K, and Mayan calendar as evidence against current alarms.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
2,871
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2421
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
23
2009
20
2010
50
2011
29
2012
39
2013
40
2014
52
2015
58
2016
102
2017
150
2018
151
2019
259
2020
274
2021
361
2022
321
2023
484
2024
212
2025
235
2026
8

Keywords

IPCC e.g US HN breitbart.com Y2K youarenotsosmart.com FUD freeread.com slatestarcodex.com predictions doomsday does exist prediction world climate planet climate change crisis consistently

Sample Comments

the_third_wave Sep 25, 2022 View on HN

I propose a "this doomsday does not exist" corollary to this project:- this dark age does not exist (viz. the fall of the Roman empire)- this ice age does not exist (viz. the host of ice age scares from the late 60's to 80's)- this apocalypse does not exist (viz. Mayan end of ages, comet scares, ...)- this world famine does not exist (viz. Paul Ehrlich's entire oeuvre/eschatology)- this nuclear holocaust does not exist (...yet?)- this Siberian clim

_hypx Jun 8, 2023 View on HN

So you're literally predicting the end of the world. Great.

CyberDildonics Jul 17, 2017 View on HN

Predicting a future of devestation. You would think we would be past buying into that ruse by now.

This is why I'm sceptical of any doomsday scenario. Too many times they turned out to be damp squibs. Think population bomb, peak oil etc.

sleepysysadmin Nov 26, 2021 View on HN

It's unfortunate that 'doomsday' will remain.In society there will always be the Y2K and Mayan Calendar people. Climate change is a much more reliable source compared to some ancient Mayans.There are also ideologues pushing a political position. Saying that the world ends in X years unless you do what I say is not going to go away.There are people justifying their rent. Give me grant money and I'll say the world ends in X years.

bigbugbag Feb 26, 2018 View on HN

I'm not sure what doomsday scenarios and failed predictions you're referring to but even though for some reason it feels otherwise to you evidence and argument is quite solid.Seems you may be victim of a bias of some kind here[1], or have been exposed to some misinformation of some kind.[1]: https://youaren

rsj_hn May 9, 2021 View on HN

The future of the planet cannot depend on anyone's predictions -- that's a category error.What you are referring to is "consensus", e.g. gatekeeping. This is similar to the deplatforming crisis. For some reason a lot of people are convinced that things like opinions or predictions are going to destroy their lives, or the planet, etc, who knows, perhaps even justice and gravity are at risk. It would help everyone to gain some more perspective and lay off the world-ending rh

adamrezich Dec 14, 2021 View on HN

it's a hard sell for skeptics because basically every major politically-charged doom-and-gloom x-years-from-now climate change prediction has ended up not coming to pass thus far[0]. obviously it's not like it's literally impossible for such a scenario to occur but at some point when a boy cries wolf enough times over the decades it's hard to take any headline phrased like this one immediately seriously at face value.[0] <a href="https://extinctionclock.org/

lowercased Aug 15, 2022 View on HN

But then you have things likehttps://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/50-years-of-failed-doomsday-e...which call out dozens of warnings over the past 50+ years, and seemingly didn't come true. Now some are still years off being 'done', but the tone of the piece (and many others like it) is that

KirinDave Jun 12, 2019 View on HN

> The problem with predictions like this is that this prediction will look silly in 4 years when the Earth has not endedCan you explain why people like you who come here to post "the world won't end in 4 years" consistently do not read the article, and consistently set the bar at "literally the oblate sphereoid we are on explodes" as opposed to "the climate is so radically different it threatens every aspect of human society and triggers even more mass extinct