Brexit Immigration Impact

The cluster discusses Brexit's effects on UK immigration, particularly the end of EU free movement leading to labor shortages, shifts to non-EU migrants, and debates on economic benefits of EU workers versus concerns over uncontrolled immigration.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Politics & Society
2,635
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#241
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
2
2009
8
2010
11
2011
13
2012
26
2013
44
2014
39
2015
77
2016
417
2017
295
2018
179
2019
166
2020
181
2021
269
2022
206
2023
250
2024
151
2025
290
2026
11

Keywords

US telegraph.co OK UK wordpress.com i.e EU NHS parliament.uk uk eu immigration brexit migrants migration citizens skilled uk eu immigrants

Sample Comments

TheOtherHobbes Jan 15, 2019 View on HN

The EU isn't foisting immigration on the UK.EU freedom of movement isn't unconditional. You can only move to a different EU country if you have a job or can support yourself.You have three months to make it work, and then if you can't make it work, you can be asked to leave.The UK deliberately opted out of this requirement. Until recently, the UK was one of the most generous and open states for EU immigration.The UK also made the most noise about allowing the fo

mike_hearn Dec 30, 2023 View on HN

Brexit doesn't prevent people from Europe immigrating to the UK, and was never pitched as doing that, so you might not have been representing it correctly to your in-laws unless you had no skills and were not in education when you immigrated.

rich_sasha Mar 31, 2025 View on HN

It's a funny one. The average Brit was financially better off with all these Eastern Europeans coming in and doing jobs in short supply. Around me in the UK, most shops, restaurants, preschools and many more establishments are short-staffed. This is also the real reason why migration numbers are off the charts - the vacuum of business needs sucks people in.And yet the Brits don't seem to want these people. Fine - their country, their right. But instead, free of the yoke of the EU, t

webdevver Nov 10, 2025 View on HN

nobody is going to stop you leaving the UK.its entering another country that suddenly becomes a real problem, and ofcourse, if you're in the UK, the only country worth moving to at that point is the US with (as I understand) quite stringent immigration restrictions.in reality, if the US were to open their doors to the UK, holy moly - this entire country would turn into Ukraine overnight, with nobody but pensioners left. which actually isn't in either governments interest:

smm2000 Jun 26, 2016 View on HN

I am pretty sure British are OK with you (aka somebody paying 1K/week in taxes) staying in UK. At worst you will have to get work visa with minimal efforts no matter what. In contrast to US, UK has well functioning visa system for highly qualified workersFree movement of labour benefits workers in poor countries immigrating to UK and mostly affluent/rich UK citizens working in Europe. It's of no use to middle class and down - they are not moving anywhere. If EU stopped at free

thousand_nights Nov 15, 2025 View on HN

as a casual observer living in the uk, what brexit has done is stopped the influx of highly educated and economically contributing people from the EU, and instead replaced them with people who are claiming "asylum" from asian and african countriesdownvotes ahoy

MaysonL Jun 26, 2016 View on HN

And of course, "uncontrolled immigration" also implies "uncontrolled emigration". There are quite a few British expats in the rest of Europe who may find their new work permit status uncertain. (And who found it difficult to vote in the referendum).

div Jun 27, 2016 View on HN

The point the article is trying to make wrt immigration is that when the UK leaves the EU, it will also leave the free movement of workers zone, making it harder to attract immigrants, regardless of how London feels about them.

jdiez17 Sep 2, 2017 View on HN

This is exactly how I feel about the whole Brexit mess, as an European that is working in the UK. For me, moving here was as simple as getting on a plane and handing my Spanish identity card to a customs officer. This is my benchmark for the post-Brexit immigration system: if it is one iota more inconvenient for an European like me to move to and work in the UK, I will pack up my stuff and go somewhere else, because I would not have even considered coming here in the first place if that was the

ElectricalUnion Dec 30, 2023 View on HN

From my (foreign) point of view, is that now that the UK can no longer benefit even indirectly from what used to be a large transient workforce from the border-free Schengen Area, it instead is forced to actually accept "unsightly more permanent and real immigration" from the rest of the EU and the world at large to keep the economy turning.So it went from "we don't like immigrants" to "pretty please immigrate to the UK even if you're not from the EU or we&