No True Scotsman Fallacy
Comments repeatedly invoke the 'No True Scotsman' logical fallacy, accusing others of redefining groups to exclude counterexamples, often in discussions about Scottish identity, language, or culture.
📉 Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
2,068
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2370
Topic ID
Activity Over Time
2007 3
2008 3
2009 10
2010 27
2011 38
2012 47
2013 91
2014 122
2015 105
2016 136
2017 134
2018 138
2019 167
2020 174
2021 174
2022 241
2023 155
2024 129
2025 150
2026 24
Top Contributors
Keywords
BBC US www.gov C3 news.bbc youtube.com co.uk McDuck TRUE NB scotsman true scotsman scotland true irish ireland wikipedia northern rural eh
Sample Comments
No real scotsman argument already?
This conversation is for true Scotsmen.
No true Scotsman eh? Classic for a reason!
"No True Scotsman..."
Looks like a True Scotsman to me (https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/No_True_Scotsman)
I see no true Scotsman, am I right?
This thread is about Scotland, pal.
Sounds like here in Scotland, so it must be true ;-)
The "No True Scotsware" problem? :)
Maybe "no true Scotsmxn" etc