Police-Protester Violence Debate

The cluster centers on heated debates about police violence against protesters during demonstrations like BLM and George Floyd protests, contrasting claims of excessive police brutality on peaceful crowds with arguments blaming protesters for inciting violence, riots, and looting.

➡️ Stable 0.8x Politics & Society
4,411
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2349
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
1
2009
8
2010
3
2011
40
2012
36
2013
89
2014
143
2015
58
2016
101
2017
149
2018
46
2019
339
2020
1,740
2021
774
2022
283
2023
152
2024
110
2025
280
2026
59

Keywords

LE GP BS YouTube BLM wikipedia.org police violence protestors protesters protests violent cops peaceful protesting protest

Sample Comments

newacct583 Jul 27, 2020 View on HN

This is a protest against the police. So of course the cops are going to get violent. What's horrifying is the extent to which people refuse to see that and just figure "well, the protesters have to have done something to deserve it".

throwawaythekey Sep 27, 2021 View on HN

It's closer to "police officers assaulting protesting civilians who refused to stop protesting"

CryptoBanker Aug 22, 2020 View on HN

Shittier than perpetuating violence on demonstrators?

KuiN Jun 2, 2020 View on HN

As an outsider watching from across the Atlantic, I am astonished at what is being posted in these comments. There are hundreds of videos on social media of wanton police violence towards peaceful protestors. Of course there are non-peaceful protestors (and I do not defend them) but they are responded to in incidents of heavy handed violent escalation. Bellingcat have collected more than 100 reports of protected media representatives being beaten, blinded and brutalized by police action. This is

germainelol Oct 11, 2019 View on HN

The police are phsyically attacking the people, it's quite different. Yes, this app helps protestors, but it also helps the public avoid being treated extremely violently by the police.

carb Jun 2, 2020 View on HN

If you have proof that Person A killed your neighbor, and yet they were being protected from prosecution, of course I would support your right to protest. Sometimes the only way to get change is with large public support.Unfortunately, today's news focuses only on violence and fear mongering. You will eventually realize that peaceful protests have never successfully brought change. You will find yourself screaming into a void, without justice.Today, the police claim that there are onl

refurb Jun 2, 2020 View on HN

Wait, you're blaming the police if protests turn violent?

throwawaysea Jan 30, 2021 View on HN

Do you have strong, proven evidence for infiltration? Otherwise this seems like the typical false flag conspiracy we always hear when protests turn violent. The reality is even those acting peacefully are providing cover for those acting violently among their ranks. They also often incite that violent fringe to action, and condone or overlook their actions. Silence is violence, right? And remaining silent on those using violence to achieve political goals - the very definition of terrorism - isn

spiritplumber Jun 8, 2015 View on HN

Will this work for police violence?

cheesecracker Jun 4, 2020 View on HN

Not sure how to get from being gassed by the police to looting shops, though.I haven't seen that footage, but of course I have heard of cases of violence against protesters. Doesn't really prove a deliberate approach to me. Maybe some police officers are also just human and get angry when people hurl stones at them and spit at them. If it's an excuse for the protesters, why not for the police. Sure, you'd hope they'd be trained in restraint, but at the end of the day,