Russia-Ukraine Identity Debate

The cluster focuses on debates about distinctions between Russian ethnicity, citizenship, and historical territories, questioning whether Ukraine and other ex-Soviet states are truly independent nations or extensions of Russia/USSR. Discussions highlight Soviet legacy, imperial claims, and Russian irredentism toward Russian-speaking populations abroad.

📉 Falling 0.2x Politics & Society
3,582
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2255
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
2
2009
6
2010
10
2011
22
2012
34
2013
70
2014
143
2015
69
2016
153
2017
202
2018
101
2019
210
2020
214
2021
304
2022
894
2023
478
2024
387
2025
249
2026
34

Keywords

GDR FYI USSR PRC WWI EU CAN russia russian ukraine ussr soviet russians poland ukrainian empire region

Sample Comments

go13 Apr 4, 2023 View on HN

russia and soviet union are not too far apart actually. Let's not make victim of poor russians, while so many of them fight now and fought in the past to kill independent nations.

buran Jul 26, 2019 View on HN

Russian Federation != Russia and doesn't contain a region called "Russia". Actual Russia renamed itself into Ukraine.

thriftwy Jul 3, 2024 View on HN

Russians do not think that fellow Russians stuck on the other side of a newly drawn state borders are "other nations".Just as Hungarians do not consider Hungarians from Uzhgorod an other nation; ditto Serbs do not consider Serbs from Respublika Srpska another different nation.Russians actually care very little about what all of the remaining Eastern Europeans are up to. They aren't of much interest. Why do you need Warsaw if you can fly to Paris non-stop.

Jon_Lowtek Aug 10, 2025 View on HN

there is a difference between "russian" and "russian speaking" that is quite important to many eastern europeans that do not wish to be part of some kreml lead lingua-nation.

iaskwhy Mar 1, 2014 View on HN

Not Russian territory but under Soviet (and then Russian) influence. No?

walterlw Jul 19, 2024 View on HN

it's about the difference between "was" and "is". Sure, a bunch of states were formally parts of the Russian Empire as well as the USSR. That doesn't mean you can reduce them to "it's just Russia", those lands and peoples had history prior to being invaded and some have been lucky to have had some independence since the fall of the USSR. Considering that there are people out there literally fighting to the death not to be a part of the next russian im

thesmok Aug 28, 2023 View on HN

Russian citizenship is not something that people cherish or want. Most of the Russian territory and population has been occupied at some point: Siberia long time ago, Caucasus in the past centuries, Crimea in 2014. Russians don't care about those people the same way the care about their own.

trasz Aug 7, 2022 View on HN

More like Ukrainian, given the birthplace. USSR wasn’t Russia.

disordinary Apr 26, 2018 View on HN

I think it's hard to understand how people view their ethincity as different from their citizenship for people from countries with a colonial heritage. People who are of Russian ethnicity but live in another country like the Ukraine, or Latvia, or Lithuania, or Estonia, or any number of other former Soviet or Russian Empire states often consider themselves as Russian, they also often feel like they're marginalised in their homes and face racism so I could see the Russian ethnic regions

ROTMetro Apr 17, 2023 View on HN

Russia doesn't believe a country called Ukraine exists. Instead they believe a region called 'the Ukraine' does. Funny your choice of words.