Urban Car Parking

Discussions center on reducing parking spaces in dense cities to discourage personal car ownership and traffic, exploring alternatives like autonomous vehicles, ride-sharing, public transit, and urban planning reforms.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
3,227
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2227
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
1
2009
10
2010
17
2011
23
2012
44
2013
68
2014
79
2015
117
2016
238
2017
210
2018
343
2019
349
2020
201
2021
251
2022
300
2023
480
2024
302
2025
184
2026
9

Keywords

SO parking car cars parking lots city cities space parking lot street busses

Sample Comments

narrowtux Aug 27, 2019 View on HN

The end goal here is that people who live in big cities give up their personal car. The journey there might involve this problem though and it depends on the city to enforce new rules.For example, my home town Hamburg (in Germany) is a bad example of too few parking spaces being policed correctly. At some point, the drivers give up searching for a free space that's still in a walkable distance from their destination and will park illegally, which leads to one of 2 lanes being permanently

bcheung Aug 9, 2018 View on HN

You'd need to allocate more parking spaces then. You can have more roads if you have less parking.Also, having a car sit idle 95% of the time is not an efficient use of money. It's the same model as virtualization with servers (sharing unused capacity brings down the costs for everyone).Also, there's the tremendous amount of time wasted and hassle to park, especially in big cities that have multi-story parking garages. Especially with their "compact" parking spo

danjayh Jan 25, 2019 View on HN

I'm not sure that the drive should necessary be away from cars. With the advent of driverless cars, there is a new option: shared cars. They provide the time-savings of point-to-point transit for the already time-strapped lower class, can (optionally) enable ride sharing for cost and congestion reduction, use the existing infrastructure, and with sufficient percentage of self-driven cars should provide throughput similar to busses ... all while eliminating the need for parking in city cente

jaffeee Apr 29, 2014 View on HN

Theres already an abundance of parking real estate, there's no need to make more. Look into the predictive analytics used by Uber or Citibike to see how wait times can be minimized. When freed from the redundancy of having to use an overbuilt one-size-fits all for everything, the energy savings will more than make up for a car having to drive two or three blocks from the parking lot to the pick up zone. Shit, I could go on.

imglorp Dec 13, 2019 View on HN

Do they reduce parking usage at least?

maym86 Sep 30, 2018 View on HN

You don't need atonomous vehicles to make this work. A good public transit system within the city, decent bike lanes and some park and ride options for getting in from the outskirts could be enough to make up for the reduced parking options.

pkulak Aug 27, 2019 View on HN

Seems like an inability to store private vehicles for free on public property would reduce cars and traffic.

UtopiaPunk Jul 17, 2023 View on HN

This is a major problem, actually. Cars sit parked more often than they drive, usually. Parking a car requires kind of a lot of space, like a parking lot or a garage. Car users also expect to have a parking space at their destination, which is another parking space. Added up, the land devoted to parking is a lot. That land isn't serving any other purpose either, it can't even be nature (no plants can grown and rainwater can't permeate into the soil). That land also costs m

malandrew Sep 22, 2012 View on HN

I think you mean "cars in a city" instead of "street sweeping/parking"Once the density of people per square mile is over a certain point, the usage of cars contributes to a tragedy of the commons, inconveniencing many of the residents in the city for the benefit of few. New York has been one of the more aggressive cities in removing parking and closing down roads to car traffic and it has greatly improved the quality of life there for residents.London's Canary Wharf district is able to sup

BurningFrog Jul 21, 2016 View on HN

Parking becomes mostly obsolete, freeing up huge amounts of central city areas.