Social Media vs Real Connections

The cluster debates how social media provides illusory connections that replace or hinder genuine in-person socializing, with many advocating for real-life interactions over online surrogates.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Politics & Society
5,315
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2188
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
12
2008
23
2009
46
2010
129
2011
137
2012
150
2013
158
2014
109
2015
119
2016
220
2017
259
2018
411
2019
326
2020
344
2021
505
2022
574
2023
593
2024
439
2025
690
2026
73

Keywords

maya.land BigTech maya.l AI HN DM FWIW guess.html AND S.M social social media media friends social networks facebook real life real life networks

Sample Comments

tonyhart7 May 18, 2025 View on HN

"This sounds like parasocial connection standing in for shared cultural experience to me"no no no, you are not understand, this is the new normalgone long time a way for you to meet and socialize in your local community. this is the new wayYou just miss old times

HenryBemis Sep 24, 2019 View on HN

We have different definitions of socializing. Commenting on a piece of news or opinions to enhance our thinking and gain knowledge/motivation/ideas, I don't call that socializing. I haven't made any connections through this platform and if I don't check the HNews for a week, I don't feel sad or missing anyone. But that's me. Someone else may be more (in)vested in here and consider HN as an integral part of their social life. I won't judge them.

throaway1988 Sep 27, 2025 View on HN

a lot of people have friends but we only “interact” via a screen!

acd Sep 13, 2025 View on HN

Social media is actually anti social. Meeting real people and making real connections is social.

chaircher Feb 22, 2022 View on HN

I had this exact issue. Over time your irl social network (like your wife) cotton on that you're not in the loop and they'll contact you to tell you about things they think you're interested in. So not only is there better curation going on but you're also strengthening your bond with real people around you.

Mikho May 1, 2018 View on HN

Social networks made this happen. They give a feeling of inclusion and conversation while they are just a surrogate and imitation of a real human connection. Previously one had to make itself go out to meet real people and train itself to be social in real life -- being alone at home was too lonely.Today sitting in front of a screen with a beer in a kitchen and participating in some absolutely irrelevant to our life flame with people one doesn't know and doesn't care about gives a p

a5c11 Jul 11, 2025 View on HN

Hopefully. I feel like people actually stopped socialising after the social media breakthrough. It's harder to ask friends out for a coffee or beer because "nah, we can just talk online". We have locked ourselves in virtual communities where we have a false feeling of importance. Boards were the last acceptable form of socialising, but it was different, it was aimed at exchanging knowledge and common interest, not replacing real interactions completely.

gregjor Oct 6, 2023 View on HN

Get off social networks. Real connections happen in real life.

chetanahuja Oct 20, 2013 View on HN

"a social utility, the lack of which meant losing touch with friends, not being invited to events, and generally missing out on a large amount of social interaction"And according to the article (and my own, admittedly limited, survey of teens and "tweens" I know), that utility value doesn't exist anymore. Now, you could argue that the thing they are moving to is also facebook under a different name (instagram)... but I suspect it would be just as ephemeral as a

goodpoint Aug 14, 2023 View on HN

Completely wrong. People are glued to social networks & co precisely because it mimics social interaction.