Human Need for Religion

Comments debate the inevitability and social utility of religion, arguing that humans require it for psychological and communal purposes, and that it persists or morphs into secular ideologies like politics, technology worship, or AI cults even as traditional faiths decline.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
4,471
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2166
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
39
2009
71
2010
66
2011
76
2012
138
2013
102
2014
126
2015
182
2016
208
2017
263
2018
269
2019
354
2020
284
2021
692
2022
470
2023
495
2024
302
2025
306
2026
25

Keywords

e.g US AI BS DNA LSD OSI washington.edu GDP GNU religion religions religious beliefs social humans belief values psychology god

Sample Comments

coldtea May 8, 2016 View on HN

That's a rather naive, if popular, view of religion.Probably made even more popular by the fact that in the US any kind of fringe BS can pass as a religion, from Scientology to what have you.And by fringe I don't mean less true in the "god exists" way (well, he doesn't exist, at least not in any religious guise), but less historically established and having served an important societal role.Because religions were an early cultural framework for formulation of a

helthanatos Apr 28, 2017 View on HN

It could be because religion is useful

rick888 Mar 22, 2011 View on HN

If all religions were gone tomorrow, the burden on society would still be there in another form. There are many people religious about global warming, Linux, the GNU, styles of politics and economics, etc. Even some political figures are followed religiously to a point (where logic and reason are out the door when you try to have a conversation questioning them).Religion isn't all bad. There are people that take it to the extremes, but many of the things in the bible teach you to be a bett

HumanHater Nov 21, 2018 View on HN

Humans wants religion, humans need religion, a lot of humans can't survive without religion. All those reports about religion decline in the world look misleading. It is just Christian God fell out of favor and a lot of people choose to worship Holy Technological Progress. You can easily recognize worshipers of his two main sects in threads like this.First one claims that you don't need to worry about Climate Change, Super AI, Antibiotic Resistance Pathogens etc because Holy Progres

Teelemii Aug 21, 2022 View on HN

Most people with religious beliefs and churches themselves don't reevaluate the things you mentioned.Otherwise the world would be a totally different place.Just because you can see ego min and max things in theory it doesn't mean it has a real influence in people.Religios people lifing a 'good' life and as soon as someone needs help all is gone.Plenty of sexual abuse have happened and is probably still happening.You yourself brought it up.And then we have th

roenxi Jun 13, 2021 View on HN

Being religious isn't a weakness, it is an inevitability. A human mind is very limited and not up to the challenge of understanding everything - people have to accept most of their knowledge through social proof. Once social proof is involved religious-looking structures evolve rapidly. It isn't a matter of having or not having cognitive tools, it is that the tools necessary to avoid faith and community can't exist. At least without a level of change that shatters what it means to

exporectomy Jan 27, 2021 View on HN

Not many cultures have ever been free from widespread pervasive detachment from reality. By default, that's religion, though some political ideologies and superstitions have also filled that need. If you really don't like it, you probably don't like humans. And I tend to agree, humans have a fault in their brains causing irrational beliefs, but it probably serves some more valuable purpose than being right.

darkclarity Mar 25, 2016 View on HN

With a lack of religion, people naturally seek idols to look up to and create a focus in their lives. That said, it can go too far and look like a cult. The more I read about behaviour, history and psychology, the more I realise just how specialised religions were at keeping civilisations sane.

mmagin Jun 17, 2018 View on HN

At least in my experience, as a gen-X person in the US:For at least a generation now, organized religions have been doing a poor job of addressing people's personal spiritual needs, while at the same time being the bastion of various sorts of social conservatism with justifications that often don't hold up in the context of modern scientific knowledge.Now, I do think this is sometimes quite unfortunate, as it sometimes leaves these people easy prey to even less rationalistic reli

FredPret Nov 19, 2021 View on HN

Society has left religion behind but dogma is still with us