Windows vs Unix CLI

The cluster debates the quality and usability of Windows command line tools like PowerShell, WSL, and Terminal compared to Unix/Linux shells, with users discussing preferences, improvements, and whether Windows needs more Unix-like CLI features.

πŸ“‰ Falling 0.5x DevOps & Infrastructure
2,809
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#2077
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
21
2009
54
2010
49
2011
82
2012
108
2013
167
2014
135
2015
210
2016
268
2017
212
2018
211
2019
149
2020
143
2021
213
2022
202
2023
183
2024
220
2025
165
2026
14

Keywords

MS COM IT e.g CLI MUCH PC SSH UNIX UI windows command line command powershell unix terminal line linux cli nix

Sample Comments

righthand β€’ Sep 11, 2024 β€’ View on HN

Honestly there are so many differences and little things on Windows that make using any of the CLIs not worth it. You will run up against gotchas developing on native Windows cmd, Powershell, git bash, and WSL. I left for Linux a long time ago and never have had to look back at the utter mess that is Windows. People stay on that platform for what? A graphical menu in the corner? Compatibility you don’t actually need? Use a real shell and OS and save your sanity.

mnky9800n β€’ Jul 31, 2021 β€’ View on HN

I feel like, modern extensions of the Microsoft command line excluded, I use Linux for one thing and windows for another. I've yet to have a windowing environment that simply works like windows does in Linux. The same is true for my experience in the terminal but visa versa. Different tools for different jobs. But, it's 2021 not 1999. Maybe times were different then.

vertex-four β€’ May 21, 2014 β€’ View on HN

Why are you using Windows if you want it to behave like Unix?

dmead β€’ Feb 9, 2024 β€’ View on HN

Why don't you guys just use a regular shell? People just want a unix like command line. Windows seems to be doing a lot of work to avoid this.

ModernMech β€’ Oct 22, 2021 β€’ View on HN

This is an issue with their proficiency, not their OS. Windows Terminal is amazing, as it integrates PowerShell with WSL; you can run a full bash session in Ubuntu on Windows next to a full PowerShell instance. I can start my Windows laptop directly to a console, and never even look at a GUI.edit: I think the sibling comment is making the same point. Here is the link: https://do

ComradePhil β€’ Apr 18, 2022 β€’ View on HN

Windows has a MUCH superior cli these days because of WSL.

romanovcode β€’ May 12, 2018 β€’ View on HN

I use MacBook at work and Windows at home.> Unix ShellCmder[0] is what I use, it supports all commands that I use on my work MacBook. If I need something Linux-specific like imagemagick, I just use WSL[1]. Some say it's slow but it runs fine. Maybe it's the fact that my PC is like 10x more powerful than my MacBook Pro because it's standard desktop computer with water cooling.Bottom line, as someone who is using both every day - Windows is fine, it's not 2010 anymo

evfanknitram β€’ Aug 3, 2018 β€’ View on HN

In Windows there's been a lot less emphasis on the terminal since most functionality has only been configurable using the UI. This is changing now.Your post is a little like complaining over a functional programming language adding OO-features or vice versa and saying they are late to the party.

Zardoz84 β€’ Mar 4, 2016 β€’ View on HN

Yes, when you are forced to work on windows and you need sane CLI tools and a decent shell.

ktpsns β€’ Dec 12, 2017 β€’ View on HN

This is so true. Another attemp to explain might be: The cmd.exe and PuTTy always feel like foreign bodies in the windows world, they don't integrate, they are an rough try to fill the gap between the "old" command line world and the "new" windows world (in the win95 language). In contrast, already the OS X terminal feels like a first class citizen in the environment.It is worth to emphasize what has been said before here: Since Windows popularity is decending, they s