Clothing Donation Critique

Comments debate the harms of donating used clothing to developing countries, including damage to local industries, massive waste from fast fashion, and promotion of cheap disposability, while suggesting alternatives like repair, reuse, or reducing consumption.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
1,774
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1974
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
2
2009
1
2010
11
2011
29
2012
28
2013
18
2014
24
2015
37
2016
38
2017
53
2018
154
2019
190
2020
191
2021
195
2022
300
2023
208
2024
164
2025
126
2026
5

Keywords

www.npr OP HN ThredUp fastcompany.com clothes clothing fashion wear garbage fibers disposal worn second hand stores

Sample Comments

BurningFrog • Apr 28, 2024 • View on HN

My understanding is that these days clothing is so cheap that there really isn't a lot of people who lack clothing anymore. Even in the poorest corners of the world, people have a few sets of clothing and maybe even shoes.This is huge progress compared to the old days, when many people only had one set of clothes, and had to wash them naked.If the price for this is a lot of clothing trash, that seems a pretty great bargain to me.

tingletech • Aug 11, 2022 • View on HN

why not fix or recycle old clothes?

Cthulhu_ • Jul 2, 2025 • View on HN

Perhaps, but if clothes are cheap, income is disposable and fashion is fast, why bother?Other than jeans, shoes, socks and underwear, I haven't worn through or grown out of anything in forever, nothing to pass on really.That said, the textile collection and resale industry is huge; stuff gets sorted, parts go to secondhand shops and charity, part gets baled up and exported, parts get recycled, etc. Same with electronics, it ends up in low-wage countries in Africa and south-Asia where

daveguy • Jan 16, 2025 • View on HN

The HN headline doesn't reflect the statement. Do not donate used clothing.

pedalpete • Dec 5, 2020 • View on HN

Old clothes aren't the issue, it's the resources needed to make new clothes.

Apocryphon • Jun 28, 2022 • View on HN

Why don't you just donate the clothing?

tshaddox • Jul 19, 2021 • View on HN

Don’t some clothing stores also destroy all the clothes they discard so that they can’t be resold?

dylan604 • Jan 21, 2024 • View on HN

why not straight to the trash. why would you feel that some article of clothing that is so poorly made that you refuse to wear it should be foisted upon someone else? this just feels like you trying to make yourself feel good without actually doing any good.

nine_k • Nov 28, 2019 • View on HN

That would be planned obsolescence of clothes.

Ekaros • Feb 26, 2023 • View on HN

Why don't developed countries reuse the clothing there? Save the shipping. Maybe force the stores also to sell second-hand clothes with new clothes.