Neighborhood Walkability Debate

Commenters share personal experiences on distances to everyday amenities like grocery stores, shops, and restaurants in suburbs versus walkable urban or town neighborhoods, often contrasting car-dependent U.S. suburbs with more accessible areas.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
2,800
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1818
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
6
2009
12
2010
29
2011
39
2012
55
2013
51
2014
73
2015
73
2016
124
2017
152
2018
194
2019
241
2020
198
2021
258
2022
353
2023
460
2024
252
2025
211
2026
20

Keywords

LA US SIZE HOMES MV google.com McDonalds walk grocery minutes miles miles away walking live store restaurants city

Sample Comments

matwood May 8, 2016 View on HN

This is exactly the kind of neighborhood (suburb?) I live in. I can walk/drive/bicycle to the nearby grocery/pub/cleaners. The city is ~1/2 hour drive though.

rdedev Aug 7, 2021 View on HN

You could get something like this if there is good public transport between points. Like the place where I am staying now, its relatively less crowded than the inner cities. I can walk and get any essential items like milk or meat. If I need something that I cant get, just take a bus and shop in the city. Most of the time, my daily needs are met near my home itself

bratwurst3000 Dec 23, 2024 View on HN

thanks this explains so much. was a bit stunned that all shoping possibilities are so far away from the homes

kellyhclay Jan 5, 2012 View on HN

Yes, they do :) My nearest shopping area (starbucks/grocery store/dry cleaner) is 7 miles away and the nearest "city" with a Target, fast food and a small mall is a 45 minute drive.

charcircuit Jul 1, 2022 View on HN

Not everyone lives in a city. I don't want to spend hours walking to the nearest equivalent of a konbini and back.

SomeCallMeTim Feb 2, 2017 View on HN

I live in a small suburban city and I can walk to:* The library (5 minutes)* A supermarket (8 minutes)* A dozen restaurants (7-15 minutes; mostly local restaurants + 2 fast food chains)* Two liquor stores* A drug store (12 minutes)* A coworking space (15 minutes)* Several antique stores (12-15 minutes)* (Almost forgot) Walmart (10 minutes)* Two barbers (8-12 minutes)* At least three major bus linesAnd if I get on a bike, I can go across the entire town in 20 minu

throwaway9980 Aug 7, 2021 View on HN

Towns tend to be this way, not so much cities. I live in a single family neighborhood in a large city and it’s both walkable and drivable. It’s not great driving beyond a 1-2 mile radius, but I don’t need to go that far more than once a week. My kids’ schools are all walkable distances, 30 minutes tops, or a 5 minute drive. Same for the gym, restaurants, bars, the grocery stores, etc.

BurningFrog Jun 21, 2019 View on HN

It doesn't have to be walking distance to be shorter than where people are currently driving from!!

adrian17 Sep 10, 2025 View on HN

There's a huge spectrum between dense city center and suburbia; at present, I do consider my area to be "walkable", but it's not anywhere close to a dense city and there sure aren't "corporate HQs" anywhere nearby.I do value having several gyms and restaurants (and friends) within just a short bike ride from my current house; and since one of the gyms I visit regularly is in the shopping mall, if I have an interest to cook something specific, I can buy whate

jakeludington Jan 5, 2012 View on HN

My current home is 2 miles from the nearest retail district, but I previously lived just under a mile from 90% of the places I shopped. Because of the road layouts, it was easier to drive for some things than walk.