Drug Legalization and Cartels

Comments debate whether legalizing or decriminalizing drugs would undermine cartels and gangs by removing their primary revenue source, or if criminals would shift to other illegal activities like violence, trafficking, or harder drugs.

📉 Falling 0.4x Politics & Society
4,827
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1647
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
3
2008
10
2009
76
2010
127
2011
107
2012
205
2013
344
2014
310
2015
319
2016
283
2017
362
2018
291
2019
295
2020
376
2021
488
2022
284
2023
457
2024
214
2025
257
2026
19

Keywords

www.wect latimes.com LOT US IMO E.g UK MDMA longnow.org EU drugs drug cartels illegal prohibition trade legal trafficking police underground

Sample Comments

m3kw9 Jun 26, 2019 View on HN

Wouldn’t this cause issues like drug dealers?

gregbair Mar 27, 2012 View on HN

I'm not, I was simply saying that if all those things were legal, criminals (the cartels, not the users) would find something else illegal to peddle. These people look for an easy buck, and right now, that happens to be in illicit drugs. Take that profit away, and they'll just find something else.

kansface Feb 19, 2013 View on HN

Drugs are the big money maker similar to alcohol during prohibition. Legalization would dramatically reduce the power of gangs and cartels.

dllthomas Oct 4, 2013 View on HN

Decriminalization of drugs does not answer the entire question - other illegal commerce was taking place there.

louhike Aug 12, 2014 View on HN

They might specialize in other drugs like cocain, heroin, MDMA, etc. This kind of drugs may never be legalized and there will probably still be people buying it. But it might harder to enter in this market as people selling it are often quite organized and violents (apart maybe the last seller on the chain).

valuearb Jul 20, 2017 View on HN

Then legalize drugs so they can't make that kind of money.

kiba May 31, 2021 View on HN

Why would the cartels want to legalize drugs?

durnygbur Mar 24, 2022 View on HN

Nice try, intelligence agencies. Drugs are illegal but still bought and sold which means the state has monopoly on their trade, while also has monopoly on escalation of violence. Fundamental condition is having plugs in the law enforcement and intelligence agencies. Without plugs one has immediate full attention of law enforcement and of competition.

adrianN Aug 8, 2019 View on HN

Selling drugs is a money source for organizations that do things you generally don't want to legalize.

freewhiffy Dec 11, 2013 View on HN

The police won't be "out of the way" if the cartels continue with murder, selling to minors, underage workers, kidnapping, tax evasion etc. Those are all still crimes even if hard drugs were made legal. The cartels would have to choose between going legit, and delivering goods like coors, malboro etc, or continuing their other illegal activities and get taken down by the police