Job Rejection Feedback

This cluster discusses frustrations with companies not providing feedback or reasons for rejecting job applications, including pre- and post-interview stages, legal liabilities, employer perspectives, and calls for better communication.

📉 Falling 0.4x Career & Jobs
4,975
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1577
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
25
2008
27
2009
44
2010
150
2011
148
2012
201
2013
247
2014
222
2015
390
2016
353
2017
349
2018
395
2019
336
2020
376
2021
357
2022
425
2023
325
2024
316
2025
283
2026
6

Keywords

WISH FEEDBACK NOTHING OP XYZ IMO LEGO HR PLEASE ATS feedback rejection interview rejected reject candidate hiring company job candidates

Sample Comments

kalvisk • Sep 3, 2020 • View on HN

Saddest part is that if someone declines / folds Your application w/o interview, they are hesitant to provide constructive(good, bad) feedback :/

gorbachev • Jul 12, 2016 • View on HN

If you didn't get any feedback as to why you were rejected, there's no point in feeling bad about it.There are all kinds of reasons companies reject candidates. A lot of them have nothing to do with your competence.Maybe they had a better or cheaper candidate come along. Maybe the open position was closed. Maybe they thought you were overqualified. Maybe the interviewer(s) had a bad day and rejected everyone. Maybe one of the interviewers is an asshole and vetoed your candidacy o

komali2 • Feb 13, 2018 • View on HN

When you ask them why they turned you down, what do they say? Have you tried asking for resume feedback?

vsri • Aug 29, 2025 • View on HN

Hey, I feel you on rejection - it stings. Just remember that, like any company, that place is just a collection of humans making imperfect decisions with limited information. Trust me. Your worth isn't defined by one hiring decision.

bitwize • Dec 2, 2021 • View on HN

Never expect feedback for why you were rejected. It is in the company's best interest not to explain to you why; any feedback could potentially expose them to legal liability.

jamesdhutton • Jul 26, 2022 • View on HN

Question for OP: did you attend an interview? In my experience, companies will usually provide a rejection reason if an interview has taken place, especially if you have been through multiple rounds.

ammon • Mar 8, 2016 • View on HN

I totally agree with this. Companies should give (constructive) feedback when they say no. They do not partially out of a fear of being sued, but also because they often don't know really why the reject people. The default state at most companies is rejection. If no one really liked you during the interviews, at most companies this will result in a rejection.We're doing this differently at Triplebyte. We give everyone we don't work with (who does our final interview) a several

rexreed • Feb 23, 2011 • View on HN

As a tech employer, I can tell you the top 3 reasons why it's hard to provide the feedback you seek:1) Many times it's not that you're lacking in any manner, it's just that there's someone that suited the position better. It's like dating - if you reject someone because someone better came into your life, what do you tell the other person? Usually it goes "it's not you, it's me...".2) Sometimes I don't know what I'm looking for until I look. Then I get responses and realize I'm looking for

the_jends • Jan 21, 2023 • View on HN

I think this write up is a good resource for those who got called into at least an interview. I wonder how does one improve if the rejections come even before a single interview? At that stage companies typically will not give you any reason for the rejection either for legal reasons or simply convenience. This leaves you hesitating whether to apply to other companies for fear they will reject you for the same unknown reason.Maybe someone who has been in the other side of equation can explain

kmoser • Aug 14, 2025 • View on HN

Have you tried asking them whey they didn't select you? If you express genuine disappointment and ask what it was about you that didn't fit what they were looking for, there's a reasonable chance they'll give you feedback on the interview.