D&D Tabletop RPGs

Users frequently compare the article's subject to Dungeons & Dragons gameplay, discussing preferences for roleplaying styles, criticisms of D&D, alternatives like Pathfinder or Paranoia, and experiences with tabletop RPGs.

📉 Falling 0.3x Gaming
2,887
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1482
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
1
2008
5
2009
21
2010
19
2011
16
2012
18
2013
23
2014
89
2015
43
2016
88
2017
186
2018
119
2019
189
2020
176
2021
274
2022
303
2023
638
2024
413
2025
250
2026
16

Keywords

e.g TON RPG DM STOP E.g GPT4 xkcd.com TSR youtube.com game dm players rpg play games dice playing player character

Sample Comments

viraptor Jul 30, 2010 View on HN

Sounds like a standard session of D&D.

daemonk Jan 16, 2015 View on HN

It's like a more socially acceptable dungeons and dragons.

pavel_lishin Jul 3, 2025 View on HN

I'm heavy into roleplay, and that's how I prefer to play D&D.And I think you're probably right.D&D is barely the right fit for the kind of game I like to play. But D&D is wildly popular, and it's much easier to find people who'll play D&D with a heavy emphasis on roleplay, than it is to find people who'll play Heart, or Wildsea, or things that are even further way from the "roll-play" aspect.For what it's worth, we stil

mnky9800n Jan 26, 2024 View on HN

I got fed up with DnD (and roleplaying games in general) for the following reasons:* The Emperor has no clothes. Dungeons and Dragons suffers from the very thing that makes it great, all you actually need is imagination. Any rule set and you simply can know in your mind and explain to players. There are many open rule sets if you want a rule book. Thus, there is literally no reason to buy any of the books, figures, etc. unless of course you want them. But then, this is exactly why Wizards of

lucidguppy Mar 25, 2025 View on HN

I wonder if there's a D&D setting like this.

fjsolwmv Dec 8, 2018 View on HN

What's wrong with D&D?

zaarn Jan 7, 2020 View on HN

You could look into Pathfinder, it's very crunchy with lots of options so it should fit.On the other hand, how you experience D&D depends heavily on the GM. If social solutions to problems are not rewarded, players may feel like playing a board game. Same for GMs that railroad the story too much.

Rd6n6 Aug 1, 2021 View on HN

I thought this was just going to suggest you play old school dungeons and dragonshttps://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wL7lEwD1uGI

magnusmundus Dec 19, 2023 View on HN

D&D is an example of a tabletop RPG, yes.> no one around me would want to sacrifice themselvesIt's not so much a sacrifice as it is simply a different game. Some people enjoy coming up with stories more than exploring other people's stories.

daear Feb 6, 2023 View on HN

> Dungeons & Dragons with less fighting and more trolley problemIntrigued! I'm a lapsed GM, largely because of the time commitment required to run a campaign, but this got my attention. Looks like there's enough setting and rules to spur games onward but not enough to constrain or overwhelm.Registered an account and will look into it in more detail tomorrow!