Court Ruling Disputes
Commenters heavily debate the existence, validity, interpretation, and authority of a specific court ruling referenced in the HN article, frequently requesting links to the judgment, case law, or rationale while questioning if precedents were set or overturned.
Activity Over Time
Top Contributors
Keywords
Sample Comments
Judging by this ruling, evidently not.
do you have a link handy for the appeals judgement?
That is an incredible claim. Please link to this court judgement.
yes, but that's for the court to decide.
Can you link me to this “ruling?”
How much authority/jurisdiction does this judge/ruling have? It seems like the kind of thing that might easily get appealed and lost.
The Supreme Court makes the rulings and apparently disagrees with you.
Not necessarily; that issue wasn't before the court.
Flagged because the courts decision is not mentioned in the article, so it's misleading headline.
can you provide a correct interpretation of the ruling?