Copyright Duration Debate

The cluster focuses on criticisms of excessively long copyright terms (e.g., life +70 years or 95 years from publication), their historical extensions, corporate influence like Disney, and proposals for shorter durations, renewal fees, or reforms to better incentivize creation and expand the public domain.

📉 Falling 0.3x Legal
5,178
Comments
20
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1358
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2007
10
2008
8
2009
36
2010
65
2011
132
2012
264
2013
317
2014
172
2015
264
2016
229
2017
161
2018
424
2019
226
2020
339
2021
428
2022
518
2023
713
2024
480
2025
359
2026
33

Keywords

Lessigcopyright.html e.g MOUSE US duke.edu GP THE POV theatlantic.com OK copyright disney public domain author copyrights works domain rights 14 years public

Sample Comments

mathstuf Jan 3, 2025 View on HN

At least in the US, copyright is a monopoly on certain rights for a limited time. By locking those rights for an extended time, it is stretching that definition. The time to benefit from your creations is in that time window. That goes for my creations, yours, and everyone else too. Public domain is patient, but I don't think it is worth depriving it of moderately older works with which others can start to use as a foundation to build upon.

zirgs Jun 1, 2023 View on HN

How do I benefit from 90 years long copyright terms?

_ph_ Apr 4, 2025 View on HN

Not forever. But 75 years after the death of the creator by current international agreement. I definitely think that the exact terms of copyright should be revisited - a lot of usages should be allowed like 50 years of publishing a piece of work. But that needs to be agreed upon and converted into law. Till then, one should expect everyone, especially large corporations, to stick to the law.

mtgx Oct 4, 2022 View on HN

Probably around 7-10 years, which is the time limit it originally had.Copyright is meant to be a "public pact" to encourage creation and innovation.But think about that goal for a minute. It doesn't necessarily mean you should be able to create one awesome thing once and then benefit from it for life as a rent-seeking fat cat.Instead, it should give you a reasonable amount of time to benefit from the fruits of it, but afterward, you should be encouraged to create again. S

blagie Jan 8, 2024 View on HN

You're beating up a strawman. No one (sane and uncorrupt) is arguing for life+70.However, a mechanism which works for Star Wars and Mickey Mouse, but not for a short story, a play, or a specialized piece of software written by a single individual which e.g. generates $20k / year, doesn't work for me.The length of the copyright shouldn't be proportional to the effort invested in the work. If a book my parents wrote is supposed to move into the public domain, so should St

dylan604 Oct 16, 2021 View on HN

Hahaha, that's their creative touch so they can claim copyright on this for the next 70 years

DamnInteresting Jun 22, 2024 View on HN

I am an author who relies on copyright for part of my living, yet I agree that copyright protection lasts too long. I feel like it should protect the work for a reasonable time--say 20 years--after which one must pay an initially modest but exponentially increasing fee to renew the copyright every X years. Big players like Disney could afford to keep their stuff out of the public domain for a while, but not forever. And many deceased artists' work would slip into the public domain when thei

loup-vaillant Sep 3, 2014 View on HN

Copyright never expires: it gets extended faster than time itself.

LadyCailin Feb 21, 2025 View on HN

No, copyrights make sense to be longer. But not “century” long. But something like 15 years for a copyright, renewable each year after for a growing cost, up to 30 years total, seems reasonable to me.The main point being, if you’re still making money hand over fist from your book you wrote, or film you made, you can keep the copyright. But at some point, you have to prove it has value by paying for it, with a fast growing price each year after, and still a finite time where the copyright goes

nico May 9, 2025 View on HN

It’s wild that copyright lasts this long (life of author + 70 years after death)