Bitcoin Volatility Debate

The cluster focuses on debates about Bitcoin's high price volatility compared to stable fiat currencies like USD or EUR, questioning its suitability as a currency for pricing goods, storing value, or everyday transactions, and speculating on future stabilization.

📉 Falling 0.2x Finance & Crypto
2,563
Comments
18
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1333
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
1
2010
1
2011
66
2012
61
2013
553
2014
145
2015
76
2016
53
2017
352
2018
172
2019
80
2020
95
2021
468
2022
209
2023
113
2024
42
2025
75
2026
1

Keywords

US IRL EUR steamcommunity.com ECB BTC Mt.Gox USD ETF bitcoin volatile volatility currency usd value currencies btc bitcoins stable

Sample Comments

verdverm Mar 31, 2022 View on HN

Bitcoin is too volatile, when will it become stable enough to be used for pricing IRL goods?

toyg Jan 1, 2021 View on HN

Except Bitcoin has no way to “stabilize”. Without central banks’ intervention and governance, even regular currencies would fluctuate like crazy. Unless the bitcoin world can come up with a Federal Reserve / ECB equivalent, it will continue to be a wild ride, which will effectively impede further uses. It will always be a speculation vehicle rather than a store of value.

bfwi Feb 12, 2013 View on HN

Bitcoin is unusually volatile. The exchange rate of eg. USD to EUR is much more stable.

chii Nov 1, 2023 View on HN

which would've been bitcoin, if it wasnt so volatile and unstable.

thehappypm Jun 28, 2021 View on HN

So your argument is that right now, the value of 1 Bitcoin is volatile, when compared to things like dollars or apples. In the future, the perspective will flip, and 1 Bitcoin will be considered stable, and the value of apples will be what is considered volatile?

oleganza Sep 8, 2021 View on HN

Bitcoin is volatile not in relation to USD, but to "real prices". USD or EUR are just more stable in relation to those, so it's convenient to measure BTC in USD. You can't fix the prices in BTC because you'd soon find that you are overpricing or underpricing in relation to real supply and demand of all the stuff around.

grey-area Nov 27, 2012 View on HN

Volatility is a concern if you want BTC to be a viable currency for storing value and setting prices rather than just a quick medium of exchange. Currencies like USD may fluctuate but they are a bet on the long-term stability of the US, and are tightly regulated, even if that power is sometimes abused to debase the currency.One of the main problems with Bitcoin from my perspective is that nothing backs its value; the value is unregulated and purely arbitrary and thus subject to all kinds of m

afiori Mar 3, 2021 View on HN

That is because BTC extremely unstable, which is good for speculation but not for a currency

ranger207 Aug 14, 2025 View on HN

Bitcoin's high volatility means that it's impossible to predict exactly how much value one Bitcoin will have tomorrow, next month, next year, or next decade. USD has comparatively low volatility. It's possible, but very unlikely, for USD to go to zero tomorrow, and while the uncertainty around exactly how likely USD is to collapse increases as you look further towards the future, most people would consider it less likely for USD to collapse than Bitcoin. Since markets are made up

ZenoArrow Mar 2, 2014 View on HN

Let's be clear about what is fluctuating, it is the value of bitcoins compared to other currencies. At this stage, the market value of bitcoin compared to the US dollar (for example) is not yet firmly established. Events like the Mt.Gox scandal and moves by governments to block bitcoin trading has knocked back the price of bitcoin, but these are early days for cryptocurrencies, a few shifts in the maturity of the market should ensure a more stable future as long as they are popular. These s