Pedestrian Crosswalk Rights

Discussions focus on pedestrian right-of-way laws at crosswalks, jaywalking enforcement, driver compliance issues, and safety concerns, often contrasting US practices with other countries.

📉 Falling 0.3x Politics & Society
4,130
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1159
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
2
2009
5
2010
32
2011
19
2012
42
2013
147
2014
121
2015
152
2016
214
2017
264
2018
466
2019
377
2020
357
2021
283
2022
407
2023
607
2024
350
2025
280
2026
5

Keywords

US IN AT I.e AND UK wordpress.com i.e ALWAYS pedestrians pedestrian cross traffic crossing cars lights drivers road stop

Sample Comments

dumbfounder Jul 1, 2019 View on HN

Not jaywalking. It used to be that you had to cross at a crosswalk AND wait for traffic to be clear. The crosswalk was the place to cross to make sure people weren't crossing at any place they choose. But now that there are laws that require you to stop at any crosswalk with a pedestrian in it, people are crossing and they expect the cars to stop, but not every driver is in tune with this, especially those from outside the city, and it creates a dangerous situation.

userabchn Nov 30, 2023 View on HN

It irritates me when people press the crosswalk button on quiet roads (where most of the time there is nothing coming, so you can just cross) before they have even looked to see if anything is coming. Most of the time they then cross immediately and the traffic light will go red some time after they have already crossed, holding up both cars and pedestrians coming behind (who might get there shortly before the traffic light goes green again, so have to wait for that and then wait for the accumul

jcpst Oct 12, 2023 View on HN

Where I live in the US, people simply do not stop at pedestrian crosswalks. It doesn’t matter that there’s a large fluorescent sign, and bold white stripes on the road, and a person waiting to cross. I’ve even had a police officer drive straight through while I was waiting to cross.But it seems like they’re respected if you install large flashing lights that the pedestrian can activate.

dumbfounder Jun 29, 2019 View on HN

We have crosswalks without intersections, or without signals, as well as traditional crosswalks at lights with signals and walk signs. I am talking about the ones in the middle of a road with no signals at all. I am not blaming the pedestrians, I am the pedestrian a lot of the time. But blaming half the people for not stopping means that something is wrong. If there are laws that most people do not follow or have trouble following then you need to re-examine the law, no matter who is to blame. I

drcode Mar 22, 2018 View on HN

Easy, the pedestrian had to cross sometime, and they couldn't predict which of the many lanes the car would move into.

tanseydavid Feb 28, 2023 View on HN

Don't forget the "pedestrian right-of-way" law.

stagas May 22, 2022 View on HN

In Barcelona, where I used to live, you never have to think about cars if you are a pedestrian. There are two kinds of crosswalks. Those with traffic lights and those without and they're marked differently. In both cases, you never have to look if there's a car coming. If it's green, you simply cross. At the crosswalks without a traffic light, the drivers must slow down and anticipate your decision while they see you near the first sidewalk about to cross. They have to let you go

timbit42 Jun 26, 2023 View on HN

Not if there isn't a crosswalk.

wil421 Jul 12, 2017 View on HN

Same where I am in the US. If they are in the crosswalk they still have right of way.In my area they have special blinking lights near crosswalks by heavy traffic areas. You press a button to walk and it comes on instantly, speed limit is only 35 mph. There is also a special pedestrian only red light button for major road crossings. No cars use the light and it only turns on for people walking.

fingerlocks Feb 14, 2022 View on HN

“Jaywalking” is rarely enforced in most places, even if it is a law at all, so yes you can probably cross anywhere you want. That doesn’t mean traffic will yield for you when waiting to cross, which is what we’re discussing here. Definitely look both ways before crossing in the US; drivers don’t expect pedestrians to randomly appear in the middle of the street.