Smartwatches Utility Debate

The cluster centers on debates about the necessity and value of smartwatches versus smartphones, covering advantages like wrist-based notifications, health tracking, and phone-free use against drawbacks such as discomfort, battery life, and redundancy.

➡️ Stable 0.6x Hardware
5,061
Comments
18
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1141
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2009
5
2010
51
2011
70
2012
97
2013
157
2014
696
2015
636
2016
503
2017
310
2018
251
2019
250
2020
214
2021
288
2022
308
2023
404
2024
403
2025
379
2026
41

Keywords

NFC HAVE LTE p.o OS GPS UI watch phone watches wrist apple watch smart notifications wear smartphones apple

Sample Comments

bane Sep 9, 2014 View on HN

There's lots of reasons why I stopped wearing a watch (mostly due to comfort) and I have almost no desire to return to wearing one. Even before smartphones replaced watches for most people, I usually didn't wear one or sported an old fashioned pocket watch because it was more comfortable.The burden of pulling my phone out of my pocket is not so great that the tradeoff of using an expensive, clumsy, short battery-life wearable device that does some subset of what my phone already doe

diminish Mar 24, 2016 View on HN

Maybe noone needs a watch neither a smart one, anymore?

bamboozled Oct 16, 2024 View on HN

You want an Apple Watch imo, I often leave my phone behind now, I’m contactable without distractions.

wolvoleo Jan 6, 2026 View on HN

I love the bells and whistles watches and I'm not an athlete. I love it in case I forget my phone, I still get all the notifications. I can pay with it. I can watch my home security. Something like the pebble wouldn't work for me anymore. Despite being a first day Kickstarter backer. The charging doesn't bother me because for me a watch is mainly for when I'm not home.

Gigachad May 1, 2024 View on HN

Smart watches do quite a lot that my phone can’t. Primarily health/fitness tracking, and being on my wrist.This device is essentially a phone in every way but massively less functional. I can’t see a single thing it does better or more conveniently.

deelowe Apr 8, 2015 View on HN

I'm in the same boat. I received a smart watch as a gift and never use it. Pulling out my phone simply isn't enough of a hassle to warrant using the watch and the watch alone doesn't bring any new features to the table. My watch is a piece of jewelry for me and as a piece of jewelry, smart watches just aren't the same.I believe we are seeing the tipping point of technology as fashion. Others have predicted a resurgence of non-digital goods. Perhaps watches and glasses will

mpweiher Sep 25, 2022 View on HN

The point of the watch is not needing to bring you phone...

pmontra Oct 25, 2016 View on HN

What killed the smart watch for me is the watch form factor. I don't want stuff strapped to my body. I had to stop wearing a watch many years ago for a few months and I couldn't do it again since I lost the habit. It just feels unnatural. I understand that it can be laughed at, because I wear glasses. An extremely lightweight notification device inside my glasses would be the right form factor for me.

bigstrat2003 Aug 22, 2024 View on HN

Watches are superior to phones imo. It's way more convenient to simply look at your wrist than it is to dig your phone out of your pocket.

ladyanita22 Jun 30, 2020 View on HN

I just can't see how these are better than smartwatches.