Windows 8 Tablet-Desktop Unity

The cluster discusses Microsoft's Windows 8 strategy to unify desktop, laptop, and tablet experiences with Metro UI, debating whether a single OS across form factors is superior to separate mobile and desktop interfaces like iOS or Android.

➡️ Stable 0.7x Hardware
3,599
Comments
19
Years Active
5
Top Authors
#1045
Topic ID

Activity Over Time

2008
5
2009
24
2010
77
2011
395
2012
1,085
2013
477
2014
254
2015
214
2016
159
2017
195
2018
111
2019
85
2020
113
2021
102
2022
62
2023
86
2024
59
2025
82
2026
14

Keywords

MS DWM ARM OK IM WinStore snap.png wordpress.com PC UI windows tablet desktop tablets os metro microsoft phone apps rt

Sample Comments

rst Jun 19, 2012 View on HN

Desktop Windows does, but stock windows apps generally don't work well in tablet mode without adaptation. Metro (in the form of Windows Phone 7) is lagging. Windows 8 seems to be something like the two of them running on the same kernel, but unless there are apps on both "sides" that synergize well, the whole may be less than the sum of its parts.

tallanvor Sep 14, 2011 View on HN

Windows 8 isn't iOS, BB, Palm, or Android. What they're trying to show is that Windows 8 can be the OS on your desktop, your laptop, and your tablet. Microsoft has made it clear that they still consider tablets to be PCs, even if the primary input methods are different.

AJ007 Nov 2, 2011 View on HN

You didn't read the original article. The story is about microsoft not wanting to fork Windows. They want Windows 8 to work on desktops, and tablets. From the demo videos I saw, Windows 8 switch back and forth between a usable touchscreen UI and the traditional keyboard & mouse UI. That is having your cake and eating it too. And its going to piss consumers off when they think they can use Excel on their new Windows Tablet and instead get an experience akin to picking cactus nettles out of y

molecularbutter Mar 12, 2012 View on HN

Microsoft needs to break Windows 8 Metro away from the desktop and make it tablet only, why is this so hard for them to see?

kalleboo Sep 24, 2013 View on HN

Wouldn't that make it Apple's Windows 8?

pmelendez Jul 9, 2012 View on HN

I still think it's a bet... OSX isn't integrated with iOS in the same fashion of Metro/Desktop in Win8 and Android has not a real desktop version to make a comparison here. Microsoft is trying to bring the touch experience to desktops with a keyboard and a mouse and that's very risky.

dgregd Mar 12, 2012 View on HN

Users want desktops and tables. They have different UI and that's OK. You operate cars, trucks and excavators in a similar way but not exactly the same way.MS wants to translate its power from desktop monopoly to tablet market. And therefore they play against users.It seems that MS Windows team is too powerful to let smaller teams cannibalize Windows market share. "Innovators Dilemma" case?Personally I would import only tablet features which make sense for desktop OS. For example app sa

cooldeal Feb 2, 2012 View on HN

I think WP8/W8 integration is rather overblown, but the difference in approaches seems to be that Apple and Google are scaling up phone OSes to a tablet OS, whereas MS seems to be scaling down a desktop OS to a tablet, while simultaneously taking the UI paradigm of their phone OS and scaling it up to tablet/desktop.This means you can dock your Win 8 x86 tablet with a keyboard/mouse and be using the power of full Windows. You can write code for the tablet and debug it from the very same tablet

seltzered_ May 17, 2023 View on HN

I wouldn't consider it tablet-specific. More that it has an aspiration to support tablets, like the early days of windows 8.

Shamanmuni Aug 7, 2012 View on HN

Windows on the desktop is a known and reliable brand, nobody can deny that. However, Windows on the tablet is an unkown today, and people seem comfortable and used to using a non-Windows OS in their tablets and phones, it's a radically different situation.I think it's a mistake to believe that people will choose Windows 8 in their tablets and phones just because it's Windows. Otherwise it would have worked wonders with Windows CE and Windows Phone, and it didn't. There are other factors in pl